September 10, 2022
“If you steal from one author its plagiarism; if you steal from many its research.” –Wilson Wizner (1876-1933), American playwright.
Plagiarism, for the uninitiated, means using someone else's work without giving them proper credit. In academic writing, plagiarizing involves using words, ideas or information from a source without citing it correctly or giving credit.
What was once a rare medicine has now become daily bread? With reference sources like Wikipedia available at the press of computer buttons, plagiarism has become daily bread for journalists, authors and writers of research theses for doctorates. One of the latest in-depth reports on the subject is excerpted below.
Romania's plagiarism hunter becomes the hunted (06/09/2022)
Bucharest (AFP) – Romanian journalist Emilia Sercan has made it her mission to expose plagiarism at the country’s highest levels. But her latest investigation of whether the prime minister passed off other people's work as his own in his doctoral thesis has made her the target of a deluge of threats and leaked intimate photos she says are aimed at silencing her.
Sercan has exposed some 50 cases of plagiarism involving the great and good over the last seven years, showing ministers, prosecutors and judges breaking the rules when publishing books, scientific articles or PhD theses.
The latest to come into her crosshairs is Romania's premier, former general Nicolae Ciuca. In mid-January 2022, she published an investigation in the independent media outlet PressOne, accusing Ciuca of using plagiarised content in 42 pages of his 138-page 2003 doctoral thesis on military science. Since then the journalist has been the victim of a barrage of insults and hate speech on social media to the point where Sercan said she feels "in danger". "Never before have I felt targeted in such a way," said the 46-year-old writer and academic, who has filed two complaints to the police over the threats.
Ciuca, a retired four star general who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, leads the ruling National Liberal Party (PNL) after being cherry-picked by President Klaus Iohannis. The 55-year-old premier has rejected the accusations, saying he respected the academic rules of the time. "I didn't plagiarise," he insisted.
Sercan previously received a death threat in 2019 after revealing cases of plagiarism in PhD theses in the country's police academy. A Bucharest court later sentenced a rector and his deputy, who pressured a subordinate into threatening her, to a three-year suspended jail term.
But, this time stolen intimate photos taken by her fiance some 20 years ago have been used to attack her. Shortly after Sercan sent police screenshots of the images, the screenshots were published by a website in neighbouring Moldova and quickly ended up on 74 other sites, she said. Sercan accused the authorities of having "orchestrated a kompromat operation" to try to discredit her. Prosecutors opened a criminal case, but Sercan said the investigation seems to be making no progress. "They are using their power to cover their tracks and push me into silence."
Ten press freedom organisations, including Reporters Without Borders and Committee to Protect Journalists said they are "disturbed by the harassment" of Sercan -- who is also a professor of journalism at the University of Bucharest -- and have called for a thorough investigation.
"All this support meant a lot for me, but not for the Romanian prosecutors, it seems," she added, saying she was "furious and frustrated" by the lack of action. The journalist said members of the premier's party accused her of "having chosen the wrong moment" to reveal the plagiarism, and of wanting to destabilise the state with war raging in neighbouring Ukraine.
A new education bill abolishing the independent body responsible for investigating plagiarism has also angered government critics. It would also place a time limit of three years on prosecution of cases of academic misconduct.
Romania is seen as one of the most corrupt countries in the EU, and academic fraud held a particular place in its post-Communist history, with many of the country's elite accused of using it as a shortcut to power and prestige. Professor Ciprian Mihali of the University of Cluj, a specialist on the subject, said the problem has its roots in "the proliferation of universities between 1990 and 2000 after the fall of the communist regime." PhDs became the key to reaching the upper echelons of power and "we have had to deal with the development of a real plagiarism industry," he said."It's a whole line of production and networks" allowing "incompetent people to rise to vital positions" and to stay there despite criticism.
Another Romanian prime minister, Victor Ponta, was accused of plagiarism by the scientific journal Nature in 2012, but refused to step down. He was eventually forced to resign in 2015 after massive anti-corruption protests rocked the country. A few months later, the Ministry of Education stripped him of his law doctorate and he later lost a court battle to have it restored.
The subject is open to many views. What are yours? Your response, in the format given below, is welcome (Pl. scroll down a bit). Once again, welcome to reason.