Ukraine blames Russia of ‘fake propaganda’ for thwarting IAF contract


New Delhi, Oct 21 (IANS): Vyacheslav A. Boguslayev, CEO of the Ukrainian aircraft and helicopter engine manufacturing company Motor Sich, has accused Russia of initiating a "fake media propaganda" in an alleged bid to thwart his companys chances of winning the Indian Air Force MI-17V5 helicopter engine overhaul contract.

It was recently reported that Motor Sich's majority stakes were owned by the China's Skyrizon and it had access to advanced military technology. However, in a letter written to the Indian Ministry of Defence (MoD), the Motor Sich CEO has made a strong case against China holding major stakes in the company.

Though the contract has not yet been awarded but having a Chinese footprint in an Indian defence contract is a matter of concern, especially at a time when both countries are embroiled in a border scuffle for the past many months.

In his letter to Joint Secretary & Acquisition Manager (Air) Sanjai Singh, Boguslayev hits out at the Russian Federation for trying to scuttle the deal through planted articles in the media. "These articles contained false information that Motor Sich JSC is owned and operated by a Chinese company and that it does not have rights to perform ROH (repair and overhaul) of VK-2500-03 engines. In our opinion, the purpose of these articles is an attempt to discredit Motor Sich JSC and the desire to eliminate it from participation in this tender. It would be profitable for the Russian side to have no competitors in all tenders for ROH of engines for helicopters of the Indian Air Force, which would allow Russian companies to repair engines at inflated prices."

He further cites a similar previous tender of 2016 for the repair of VK-2500-03 engines for MI-17V5 helicopters, which it won eventually but not without hiccups as there too Russia apparently tried to scuttlle Ukraine's chances by similar means.

Originally known as Motorostroitel during the Soviet era, the company was re-registered in 1994 as Motor Sich through State Property Fund of Ukraine (SPFU). In 2016, Motor Sich took loan on interest from the Chinese company Skyrizon, which it has to repay with interest by 2026. Loan borrowing from China continued after the first phase as Motor Sich diversified, but the Chinese stakes gives it a five percent partnership in Motor Sich with no access to advanced defence technology, the letter clarifies. It further adds that there was, "no direct financing by China or purchase of shares or joint ventures".

Further the letter says that ownership and partnership details of Motor Sich are on its website and Ukrainian law is followed in foreign investment and economic activity.

In its communication with the IAF, Russian JSC UEC (Joint Stock Company United Engine Corporation) Klimov informed the Indian side about being the OEM (original equipment manufacturer) of the Mi-17V5 hence the overhauling of VK2500 engines of the mentioned helicopters should be undertaken by them and that they had cancelled the license to Motor Sich for any such activity in 2018.

Motor Sich in its reply establishes itself as the OEM of the VK2500 engines and acknowledges the existence of a License Agreement signed in 2002 between Motor Sich and M/s Klimov for mass production of these engines and defends its position for the contract as it is the OEM.

As for the Russian Klimov not including Motor Sich in its latest certification for overhaul contracts, the latter says such certification is unwarranted as it is the OEM - "M/s Motor Sich has all legal rights and technical capabilities to overhaul VK-2500 (-01, -02, -03) engines and no additional approvals or authorisations from the Designer (M/s Klimov) are required."

Post Soviet break-up, Ukraine got as its share of the defence industrial manufacturing base - Antonov Corporation, Zorya-Mashproekt besides Motor Sich among others. Zorya-Mashproekt has a contract with the Indian Navy for the delivery of gas turbine engines, gear boxes, and spare parts packages to be installed onboard Indian Naval warships of different classes.

Likewise Antonov aerospace company signed a $400MN deal with India for upgrading more than a 100 AN-32 military transport aircraft, for the IAF. Also known as the IAF's workhorse, 55 AN-32 aircraft have been reportedly upgraded, 46 of which have been inducted in service.

At Aero India 2019, Ukraine had brought its semi-weaponised AN-132 for demonstration in front of the Indian administration with an intention to present it as an AN-32 replacement. As most Indian weaponry is of Soviet vintage, overhaul, maintenance and replacement contracts are frequent where Russia and Ukraine mostly find themselves face-to-face, as the largest chunk of the defence industrial base was divided among these two nations after the dissolution of USSR.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • ST, Mumbai

    Wed, Oct 21 2020

    Russia has been short changing us at every opportunity they get. We ultimately paid a whopping $2.3 billion for the refit and modernisation of the 40,000 tonne carrier, formerly known as Admiral Gorshkov, originally estimated at $1.5 billion. And Russia delayed the delivery by over five years. The Mikoyan MiG-29Ks which serve onboard this carrier, now renamed INS Vikramaditya, have also been found wanting in several aspects – airframe, engine and fly-by-wire system.
    In the case of the T-90 main battle tanks, they signed a Transfer of Technology (ToT) agreement, pocketed the $1.2 billion fee and then conveniently said technologies pertaining to a key section of the turret armour were secret.
    So, it is not surprising that Russia is miffed at the probability of missing this ‘rip-off’ opportunity. Old habits die hard.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • ST, Mumbai

    Wed, Oct 21 2020

    In 2015, the Defence minister late Mr Manohar Parrikar said in Parliament that the engines were scheduled to be overhauled after every 1000 hours of flying, but the defects started showing-up after only 500 hours of flying. He also added that as many as 35 instances of engine failures were reported in 2013-14 (which is nearly three a month) and 69 instances of engine failure in the last four years.
    The IAF highlighted,"Serviceability of the aircraft is about 50% only." 
    A scathing report by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India, observed:
    ➊) Since induction in February 2010, 40 engines (62%) of twin-engined MiG-29K have been withdrawn from service/rejected due to design-related defects; ➋) the carrier-borne MiG-29K multi-role fighter aircraft is riddled with problems relating to airframe, Klimov RD MK-33 turbofan engine and fly-by-wire system”. 🤭
    So… the conclusion is – both NPO Saturn and Klimov – which are original equipment manufacturers, make ‘UNRELIABLE’ turbofan engines.
    Since the engines supplied haven't proved to be superior, there is every reason to give Ukraine's Motor Sich JSC a chance. In addition to making Turboprop and Turbofan aircraft engines, aircraft engines maintenance and overhaul of helicopter main gearboxes are among the services the Ukrainian company offers.  So why would Motor Sich have a problem servicing/overhauling the engine of the MI-17V5 Medium Lift Helicopters??

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • ST, Mumbai

    Wed, Oct 21 2020

    Propaganda has always been a tool of Communism. Russia may no longer be Communist, but old habits hard die.
    India is the most prolific milch cow of Russian military equipment manufacturers. Recurring income is derived from supply of spares and overhauls – whether it is the diesel-electric Sindhughosh/Kilo-class attack submarine, engine of Bhisma/T-90 MBTs or the NPO Saturn Al-31FP turbojet engines of the Sukhoi Su-30 MKI. So… an attempt of obfuscation/muddying the water, would be considered justified. With the country reeling under United States imposed economic sanctions from April 2018, it shouldn't come as a surprise that Russia would have no qualms about resorting to underhand means or deviousness.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Ukraine blames Russia of ‘fake propaganda’ for thwarting IAF contract



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.