Daijiworld Media Network - Alibag
Alibag, Nov 19: A court in Maharashtra's Raigad district has convicted sitting BJP MLA from Uran, Mahesh Ratanlal Baldi, in a 2010 assault case and sentenced him to three years of rigorous imprisonment.
Baldi and three others were found guilty of voluntarily causing hurt, grievous hurt, criminal intimidation and insulting the modesty of a woman in connection with the assault on Mayur Gharat, son of ONGC employee Kashinath Gharat, in Uran.
The incident took place on March 4, 2010, when Mayur was assaulted near a medical store close to Saneguruji Garden in Uran. According to the prosecution, the attack followed an earlier dispute over Mayur making calls to the daughter of one of the accused, Sunil Pednekar.

The prosecution alleged that Pednekar and his associates attacked Mayur with kicks, fists and a stick. When Mayur's parents intervened, Baldi allegedly abused his mother, Nutan Gharat, using derogatory language. He was also accused of holding Mayur from behind during the assault.
During the trial, the prosecution examined nine witnesses, including Mayur, his parents, an eyewitness and a doctor. The defence argued that the accused had been falsely implicated following a counter-complaint filed by Pednekar against the Gharat family.
However, Chief Judicial Magistrate D M Zate rejected the defence argument that the case was a counterblast to the earlier complaint. The court held that the testimonies of Mayur and his parents were consistent and trustworthy. It also observed that minor contradictions regarding the abusive words used by Baldi did not weaken the prosecution's case.
The court noted that Mayur had undergone medical treatment for 21 days and was unable to carry out his normal activities during that period. It held that his injuries qualified as grievous hurt under Section 320 of the Indian Penal Code.
Baldi, who represents the Uran constituency in the Maharashtra Assembly, was elected in the 2024 Assembly elections. At the time of the incident in 2010, he was a corporator in the Uran Municipal Council.
Rejecting Baldi's plea for probation, the court observed that a person's social standing and position could not reduce the seriousness of an offence. It also held that the possibility of imprisonment affecting his political career was not sufficient reason to grant leniency.
The court awarded Baldi three years of rigorous imprisonment under Section 325 of the IPC and another three years under Section 324. It also imposed six months' imprisonment under Section 323, one year under Section 506(II) and six months' simple imprisonment under Section 509.
All sentences will run concurrently, making the effective prison term three years. The court also directed that Rs 50,000 be paid to Mayur as compensation from the fine amount.