Dr. Singh’s Clinic


Dr. Manmohan Singh is a PhD in Economics, a subject which essentially deals with understanding human behavior when it comes to market, money and social choices. Most Economists study the situation and write reports; none of them actually sit down to applying their vast knowledge to solve problems. After churning out several books, reports and Budgets, Dr. Singh has a unique opportunity to treat two of his most challenging patients- The Kashmir Issue & Naxal Issue. Dr. Singh has been weak in Politics and unfortunately for him, he belongs to a party, without a mass-cadre, a party that survives on Political-Engineering & serving Biryani-Beer. So calling this a political problem would be a bad way to start the diagnosis. Thus he has to rely on his vast knowledge of Economics and Social Behavior.

When a plant grows in a pot and even if the pot is dug in a ground, its leaves would rarely ever come out of the pot. Similarly Dr. Singh has been a product of the system and he is unable to think out of it. He is relying on the tried-tested & failed Back Channel Diplomacy, Strict Security Deployment, All Party Meetings, CMs Meetings, Cabinet Meetings, Committee Meetings, Press Meetings and more Meetings, resulting in same old ideas.  His team consists of people who would begin quoting reports and books, when asked for Fresh “original” ideas and Ministers who would only worry about political repercussions of every decision.

Ronald Regan is considered the Best United States President and I read in his Biography that he always told his staff, “Let us do what is right and not worry about the political outcome of the decision.” Some of his decisions were hard and at times very unpopular, but created a dynamic and strong nation. Dr. Singh displayed the same grit when it came to the Nuclear Deal but on the larger problems of Kashmir and Naxalism, Dr. Singh is weak and out of ideas. His ministers are becoming intellectually arrogant and fighting over possible solutions. But all solutions come with a major component of collateral damage.  Kashmir and Naxalism may seem so distinct but both have the same medicine- An Overdose of Democracy.

Naxalism is a movement which is strong in the least developed parts of central India. It is not a movement for liberation but a system of turning India to a communist state by 2050. It is an armed guerilla struggle which has a support of a Lakh Indian Citizens and many more through coercion and intimidation. There is a debate about Naxalism in the country. While most agree on the cause of the uprising but there are disagreements the method being followed is right.

I believe that Free Democracy is the best form of Government. Amongst all forms of government known to man (& woman), this form of Government allows for real freedom of thought & economic freedom. It is the government which would allow citizens to excel according to their capabilities. Nature has one rule- “Survival of the fittest” and in the form of government, the fittest would rise and the poor would suffer. Communist Government curtail freedom and aim to undo the rule, the Government become unnatural to human sensibilities. Left with no alternative form of changing the government, revolutionaries spring up. Power is like a magnet, once you have power; one would anything to continue with it. Communist Governments become regime and subjugate their population to torture and inhumane conditions. Free Democracy has change within the system, but communist states do not have this feature to its form of Government. Most of the Communist states are formed by armed revolutions. The leaders wield the gun and one who attains power by the gun, would find it very difficult to let go it. These Governments fail and even if Naxal Movement is a success, the Regime would be a disaster for India.

While making analysis, one must remained biased, but I am a selfish Indian like everyone else and I feel the present system favors our selfishness so I would like the end of Naxalism. Not just the movement but also the reasons which fuel it, must be defeated. Victory over Naxalism would not be in an unnatural calm or in absence of conflict. Victory would be when we remove the strains of hatred among the people living in those regions.

Naxal Problem is not only a law and order one, but a social as well as an economic one. Defeating one problem will not positively change the other two. All three have to be attacked at the same time. To understand how Naxalites think, one must read the essay by Chemkuri Azad Rajkumar, a slain Naxal Leader, published in Outlook Magazine, Pg 18 July 19th 2010. He feels that the Urban Indians, who pay taxes to fund the war against the Tribal & Naxalites, see the tribal as people who need to be civilized. There is a feeling that the Urban India views the tribal as inferior uncivilized section of the society. He goes on to add that democracy is absent as leaders are authoritative figures. There is a concern that the global resources are getting concentrated in handful of persons. The displacement of over 6Crore people in the name of land acquisition is leading to destruction of lives, lands and cultures of the people. And as expected and (most probably) true, resentment against the atrocity of Security Forces and also of the ‘state sponsored goons’ called Sulwa Judam.      

The belief in Chattishghar was that since the Government is unable to provide for security of the rural villagers, hence due to Naxalite threats and intimidation, more and more people take up the Naxalite cause. The Government trained and armed Village Defense Committees- to take on the Naxal. As it is true with anyone who wields the gun, harassment in form of rape, torture, murder and extortion became common. The poor tribal got caught in the cross-fire and slowly most of these groups got out of control of the government. Many even joined ranks with the Maoist. This exercise turned out to be a disaster as it was based on an incorrect premise.

Naxalites raise a very fundamental question for the entire world- Who owns the world’s resources? Does the person who explores the mineral resources have the right to own it or the person who owned the land where the resources were found owns it? In Bellary, Reddy brothers have a Permit to mine a piece of land, but are all the minerals theirs, as they own a permit to mine from it? The Oil found in Saudi Arabia is said to belong to the country, they could sell it. Similarly the minerals found in India belong to India. The Naxalites apply the same rule to the local village community that the minerals there belong to them. The Government may argue that they are being rehabilitated and the Corporate may argue that they built a hospital for them under their Corporate-Social Responsibility scheme. Some of them may also be employed in the mining units. But are the returns justified with respect what they are sacrificing for the benefits of others.

Dawood Ibrahim and others from the Mumbai Mafia have been made iconic figures thanks to cinema and media. But essentially they are involved in land deals where they get a bungalow owner to make way for commercial venture of apartments. These deals include threatening and murder of a few people, but in the rural areas the entire community needs to be removed, one could imagine the size of the mafia present. The armed revolution of the Naxalites could gain foothold in these areas because of the Jungle Terrain and because they were the only ones who heard their pleas and provided them protection.

Imagine a situation where you are slapped and abused by a person and then the same person comes to you without an apology but with gifts and goodies. Would you accept it whole-heartedly or would you throw it away? Well the Naxalites destroying the schools and hospitals could be seen in a similar light. Countering violence with violence would lead lots of bloodshed and deaths.  Whoever gets killed, India will lose a citizen.

I propose a solution to this problem, by making the living more democratic for them. Whenever a bill is to be passed in the Assembly or Parliament, the Government tries to create a consensus amongst all concerned parties. Hence when land acquisition is required, one should not go and impose notices, instead hold discussions with one and all over it. One must be patient for a period of at least one year. Leaders must visit these places and political parties must scout for leaders from these areas. Their concerns must reach the Parliament and a sense of belonging to the nation must be created. The government must seem responsive to them. Development and progress must not be forced on anyone.

Export of raw minerals should be banned and a processing unit must be created near the mine, to provide for employment. The valuation of the company should be such that the estimated value of the mineral resource must be taken to be the ownership of the community, while the ownership of the company should be that of the money invested in the venture. There should be annual general body meetings and the shareholders must be treated with respect. The experiment has succeeded with Renuka Sugars in Karnataka and this is in lines of trusteeship as promoted by Gandhi ji.  

There should be visible efforts to promote and protect their culture and way of life. Political parties must try to create cadres out of these tribals and even encourage leadership. Regular elections and promotion of discussions to settle grievances must be encouraged. A sense of imposing economic development or education must be removed. The British could survive in India as they began to respect Indian culture and stopped from tampering common man lives.

Guns are needed to fight the Naxals as the idea of violence must be destroyed. An over-awing sense of power and weaponry must be displayed, but not used. Their sense of belief in war should be destroyed. Dr. Singh, understanding and feeling the problem solves half of it, understanding the fuels which keep Naxalism buring bright would be a welcome first step.

Ayush Prasad - Archives:

by Ayush Prasad
To submit your article / poem / short story to Daijiworld, please email it to news@daijiworld.com mentioning 'Article/poem submission for daijiworld' in the subject line. Please note the following:

  • The article / poem / short story should be original and previously unpublished in other websites except in the personal blog of the author. We will cross-check the originality of the article, and if found to be copied from another source in whole or in parts without appropriate acknowledgment, the submission will be rejected.
  • The author of the poem / article / short story should include a brief self-introduction limited to 500 characters and his/her recent picture (optional). Pictures relevant to the article may also be sent (optional), provided they are not bound by copyright. Travelogues should be sent along with relevant pictures not sourced from the Internet. Travelogues without relevant pictures will be rejected.
  • In case of a short story / article, the write-up should be at least one-and-a-half pages in word document in Times New Roman font 12 (or, about 700-800 words). Contributors are requested to keep their write-ups limited to a maximum of four pages. Longer write-ups may be sent in parts to publish in installments. Each installment should be sent within a week of the previous installment. A single poem sent for publication should be at least 3/4th of a page in length. Multiple short poems may be submitted for single publication.
  • All submissions should be in Microsoft Word format or text file. Pictures should not be larger than 1000 pixels in width, and of good resolution. Pictures should be attached separately in the mail and may be numbered if the author wants them to be placed in order.
  • Submission of the article / poem / short story does not automatically entail that it would be published. Daijiworld editors will examine each submission and decide on its acceptance/rejection purely based on merit.
  • Daijiworld reserves the right to edit the submission if necessary for grammar and spelling, without compromising on the author's tone and message.
  • Daijiworld reserves the right to reject submissions without prior notice. Mails/calls on the status of the submission will not be entertained. Contributors are requested to be patient.
  • The article / poem / short story should not be targeted directly or indirectly at any individual/group/community. Daijiworld will not assume responsibility for factual errors in the submission.
  • Once accepted, the article / poem / short story will be published as and when we have space. Publication may take up to four weeks from the date of submission of the write-up, depending on the number of submissions we receive. No author will be published twice in succession or twice within a fortnight.
  • Time-bound articles (example, on Mother's Day) should be sent at least a week in advance. Please specify the occasion as well as the date on which you would like it published while sending the write-up.

Comment on this article

  • harini, mangalore

    Mon, Aug 09 2010

    along with this article our prime minister's caricature is appeared to be not suitable.reason is that the caricature comes very badly drawn by iran cartoonist..... the nose of manmohanji is not so long...!please obserev carefully.


  • sudarshan shetty, ganjimut/dubai

    Sun, Aug 08 2010

    One of the worst pm ever seen. A pupper in the hands of correct congress. MMS may be Mr. Clean but other used him. He is a Joker in congress party. Finance is okay for him not PM. So many scam Telephone/CWG recently but still not a word from him or MR. Bachlor Rahul Gandhi.

  • vivek, Pais

    Sun, Aug 08 2010

    Mr.R. Mallar
    could you please specify what your BJP Prime Minster Vajpayee do to the nation. If BJP had a better leadership quality then definetly they would have lead another term.

    Wat Say!!



    Sun, Aug 08 2010

    Good article by Ayush
    In fact my opinion on naxalites has changed after reading this, "where there is smoke there is fire".We need to adress the financial stability of the naxalite area.HUNGRY STOMACH WILL BE READY TO TAKE ANY RISK TO FILL THE STOMACH"

  • Antony Herbert Crasta, Mangalore/Sydney,Australia

    Sat, Aug 07 2010

    I enjoyed reading Ayush Prasad`s article. He has narrated and explained in length the actual problems faced by the Naxalities and the local community, and also the issues involved and situation existing there. For me, it was quite an informative and enlightening article on Naxalities and their movement, as I was always wondering what were all the issues, the war and the killings about. Ayush Prasad also has put forward a solution to the problem, by making the living more democratic to the Naxalites, which is worth discussing and considering.

    I would like to add though that more consensus agreements be sought on the issues and problems by involving and engaging into the Naxalite and local community leaders by the Government authorities by educating and explaining them about the real issues involved and holding meaningful discussions, rather than merely engaging into only the physical force and war, which has apparently not worked so far. I do not agree with Ayush Prsad though when he says "the Naxalites apply the same rule to the local community that the minerals there belong to them". I would apply the rule that the minerals are found in India, and as such, they belongs to India.


    Sat, Aug 07 2010


  • R Mallar, Kasaragod/ Dubai

    Sat, Aug 07 2010

    MMS may be a good person, but turned out to be a WORST prime minister. Other than he is honest what else he has done? price rise, naxalism, kashmir issue - he failed every where. And cast based cesnsus!!!! Come on, just because you hate BJP don't tell me that MMS is a good PM. I would say PVNR followed by Vajpayee are the best PMs. This I am saying not from Party loyalty, but from what they achieved despite the inherent constraints. And Rajiv Gandhi was the worst ever.

  • Langoolacharya, Belman/USA

    Sat, Aug 07 2010


    Nice article, well written with good research and carefully worded...

    Well Mr Manmohan Singh, did some good work as finance minister of india during PVN premiership, like liberalisation of trade/taxes/imports/exports etc...perhaps which lead to india being recogonised as top 20 countries in the world.

    However his naxal/Kashmir/pak policies are total failure, he cant and wont take risk, perhaps real reason for this is he was never a popular leader with mass support..please dont expect anything more from him...

    Regarding Dawood, son of a police constable, started as a small thug initially supported by people like Sharad Pawar and similar Congress Charecters, eventually supported by ISI of Pakistan..Presently sitting in Karachi printing fake indian currency and music/film piracy...illegal cricket betting/match fixing, financing bollywood movies and having affairs with heroines etc...

    Now if MANmohan has real guts in his stomach, he can close Dawood's shop in Karachi Pakistan, but how can he do this when Sharad Pawars, Praful Patels are in his cabinet Mr Ayush???

    Regarding Ronald D's comments please dont worry about them, he is a great supporter of Congress, MANmohan and Vidhvans and their wives...he thinks Congress is right , no matter what.....



  • Ronald D, Udupi

    Sat, Aug 07 2010

    There is no better person than Manamohan Singh to lead India at todays dirty politics and crisis. Karnataka politicians should learn a fraction from MMS to lead with dignity

  • Clara Lewis, Kemmannu/Dubai

    Sat, Aug 07 2010

    Good wrting by Mr.Ayush Prasad, keep writing, I feel over dose of Democracy is not only for Kashmir and Naxalities, unfortunately its true to many of our own political leaders and many of the independent groups. These are the groups in the name of religion not only spoil the image of their own community but also spoil the image of the whole country in front of the world. France questioned about the attacks on minority worship places to our PM on his visit to their country.-Gulf News.(Not sure about the date of the news and visit of our PM, If I am wrong correct me).

  • adshenoy, mangloor

    Fri, Aug 06 2010

    Fantastic and superb writing Ayush. "Manmohnomics"- Western style is rattling in India. Of course its is the Western Education of Dr. Singh. We need "Indianomics" that means raising the downtridden and marginalised.
    India is amassing guns and war planes. Can Dr.Singh change his style and introduce "Indianomics" Otherwise "Naxalnomics" will likely prevail.

  • seby, Goa

    Fri, Aug 06 2010

    Ayush Prasad is a dynamic writer we would love to read more of his stuff all the best

Leave a Comment

Title: Dr. Singh’s Clinic

You have 2000 characters left.


Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.