Mumbai Scientist Challenges Theory that Bacteria Came from Space

By Quaid Najmi

Mumbai, Aug 31 (IANS): A young Mumbai scientist claims to have disproved a theory that living bacteria from space called 'Cometary Panspermia' could have led to the origin and spread of diseases like SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) that ravaged many countries in early 2000.

In his article, 'Critique on Vindication of Panspermia', 31-year-old Pushkar Ganesh Vaidya of the Indian Astrobiology Research Centre (IARC), has challenged the theory that three micro-organisms - two bacteria and one fungus - captured from around 41 km above the earth by a team comprising renowned astrophysicist Jayant Narlikar were of cometary origin.

Vaidya's paper has been published in the latest issue of the well-known, peer-reviewed Canadian scientific journal Apeiron. (Apeiron, Vol. 16, No. 3, July 2009).

The three micro-organisms were captured through special devices fitted on balloons from earth's stratosphere in January 2001 by a team of Indian and British scientists, Vaidya said, arguing that the micro-organisms exhibited "no distinct adaptations expected to be seen in the light of the theory of evolution and the concept of niche biology."

The experiments were conducted by a team which included Narlikar of the Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics (IUCAA), Pune, and N.Chandra Wickramasinghe of the Cardiff Centre for Astrobiology in Britain. Subsequently, the team put forward the hypothesis that such micro-organisms could not travel as high as 41 km above the Earth, so they must have come from outer space.

The experiment was repeated in March 2009 and 12 bacterial and six fungal colonies were found at similar heights. According to the hypothesis, microbial life was first brought to the earth, about four billion years ago, by comets and they continue to do so. Narlikar even contended that the dreaded SARS virus came from outer space.

However, Vaidya, who analysed the characteristics of the three micro-organisms found during the 2001 experiment, said they did not show any characteristics expected in micro-organisms which lived in comets and hence must have originated from earth only.

Vaidya said the cometary environment is an extreme ecological niche and if micro-organisms are to survive in such an extreme environment for over a million years before being deposited in earth's atmosphere in a freeze-dried state, then they must adapt accordingly as per Darwin's theory of evolution.

Meanwhile, Narlikar told IANS that their research was "not intended as a theory but a suggestion for further exploration into this aspect."

"We intended that there should be more research and studies on this subject. If somebody has done it, it is good," he said.

However, in a separate written reaction, Narlikar said that he had seen Vaidya's paper and found it "somewhat superficial in its reasoning."

"One important aspect missed by the author is that these micro-organisms have not come directly from a comet. They were trapped in the Earth's atmosphere and would take some weeks to remain there as argued by the (late Sir Fred) Hoyle-Wickramasinghe theory of panspermia," he said, adding the micro-organisms would get used to gravity.

"Arguments against panspermia used to be made on the grounds that they would not survive in the hostile radiation in the interstellar space. Experiments at the Hyderabad-based Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology (CCMB) have however shown that under doses of radiation like UV, X-rays and gamma rays, bacteria mutate and learn to survive.

"I think one should be more cautious in rejecting the panspermia hypothesis and do further experimentation on microlife in interstellar space. Future work on cometary material will throw light on this issue. The author (Vaidya) rejects the panspermia hypothesis but has no suggestion as to how the micro-organisms got there from the earth," he said.

The paper was rejected by reputed journals in astrobiology several times and hence has found a place in a non-specialist magazine, Narlikar added.

On the other hand, Vaidya's mentor and biologist Arun Dholakia said the entire panspermia theory would now "change or have to be re-written."

However, he said it would take some time before the scientific community comes to terms with Vaidya's research. "But, I am happy that at least a debate has been initiated and the outcome would only benefit science and the scientific community," he said.


Top Stories

Leave a Comment

Title: Mumbai Scientist Challenges Theory that Bacteria Came from Space

You have 2000 characters left.


Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will be held responsible.