Civil Society Seeks Referendum on PM in Lokpal's Ambit


Bangalore, July 17 (IANS) Civil society members on a joint Lokpal bill drafting committee favour a referendum on the differences with the government over the inclusion of the prime minister and the higher judiciary under the proposed anti-corruption law, lawyer and panel member Prashant Bhushan said Sunday.

"We will seek a referendum on the issues such as inclusion of the prime minister and the higher judiciary in the Lokpal (ombudsman) in about 10 parliamentary constituencies, including those of central ministers Kapil Sibal and M. Veerappa Moily who are on the joint panel," he said at a programme organised by NGO Jana Sangrama Parishad here.

Contesting the stand of the government representatives on the contentious issue, Bhushan said to exclude the office of the prime minister from the Lokpal was against the basic principles of the constitution, as a corrupt prime minister was a grave threat to the country.

"As the head of the government, the prime minister leads the country and should be above board. In case of a serious graft complaint against such a high office, the incumbent should be investigated by an anti-corruption body," he asserted.

On the non-inclusion of higher judiciary in the government's draft bill, Bhushan said the official view that judges were competent to deal with the graft charges in the judiciary may not necessarily lead to unbiased and impartial judgments.

"We have suggested that all public servants, including judges in the Supreme Court and the various high courts should be brought under the ambit of the Lokpal so that no official howsoever higher is above the law," he said.

Though the civil society's draft favoured all public servants to be covered under the Lokpal, the government representatives insisted that only officers above grade 'A' would be covered in the draft bill.

Social activist Swami Agnivesh said the civil society would launch a nationwide campaign against the government if the final version of the draft bill did not incorporate the suggestions made in the Jan Lokpal bill drafted by its members.

"We are waiting for the final draft of the Lokpal bill. If the government ignores our recommendations such as including the prime minister and the higher judiciary in the Lokpal bill, we will launch a non-violent campaign across the country," he said.

Reiterating that there was no change in the stand of the civil society on bringing the prime minister under the ombudsman (Lokpal), he said it was imperative to include the top post as the prime minister also held several important portfolios.

"A Lokpal without the powers to investigate graft charges against the prime minister will lack credibility and even the government will not command respect of the people," Agnivesh added.

Recalling that former prime ministers V.P. Singh and Atal Behari Vajpayee agreed to be included under the Lokpal, he said even the current prime minister (Manmohan Singh) had earlier offered to come under the proposed ombudsman.

"What has gone wrong now? Why is the government suddenly backing out? We do not understand," Agnivesh lamented.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • vidyaji, Hyderabad, India

    Mon, Jul 25 2011

    If every Gov Office prints on every application for Gov action, should PRINT in BOLD at its TOP the bribe amount for that activity. This prevents arbitrariness as well as misuse of office.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Girish, Nagpur

    Wed, Jul 20 2011

    This referendum on the various issues of contention between Civil Society's JanLokpal bill and the Govt.'s Jokepal bill is being conducted across the country.

    The Referendum starts in the city of Nagpur from today, the 21st of July, 2011. All supporters of Anna and India Against Corruption should contribute their time and effort in helping us reach the widest cross section of the population possible. We hope to ultimately get the vote of Every Single Voter of Nagpur city.

    We'll be meeting at Sanghi Sadan, 215 Congress Nagar, Nagpur everyday at 8:00pm onwards for the duration of this Referendum. All supporters are requested to get in touch and volunteer to make this Referendum successful.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • DR.S.L.AGGARWAL MBBSDTCD(RETD), DELHI B-5/122 PASCHIM VIHAR, NEWDELHI-110063

    Tue, Jul 19 2011

    I STAND BY ALL POINTS REPEATEDLY MENTIONED BY MEMBERS OF CIVIL SOSCIETY OVER LAST 2-MONTHS AT VARIOUS PLATFORMS THERE IS NO TURNING BACK FROM HERE WHEN A STRONG-WILLED GANDHIAN "ANNAJI" HAS GIVEN THE FINAL CALL OF SACRIFICING HIS LIFE FOR THE GOOD OF THE COUNTRY . HE IS NO COWARD . I AM NOT COURAGEOUS ENOUGH TO SIT ON A "FAST-UNTO-DEATH" , BUT I CAN CERTAINLY SIT WITH HIM AS LONG AS HE IS BREATHING . AND I BELIEVE THAT 80% OF TRUE INDIANS WILL BE SITTING WITH HIM , EXCEPT THOSE WHO ARE EATING OUT OF THE HANDS OF THESE CORRUPT POLITICIANS WHO HAVE ACCUMULATED UNACCOUNTED-WEALTH IN SWISS-BANKS AND ARE MANIPULATING AND WINNING THE ELECTIONS . ANNAJI ! GOD AND THE SOUL OF GANDHIJI ARE WITH YOU .KIRANJI , PRASHANTJI , SHANTI BHUSHAN JI , ARVINDJI ARE THE BEST PERSONS AS ADVISORS FOR LEGAL POINTS PLEASE KEEP AGNIVESHJI (OTHERWISE A THOROUGH GENTLEMAN AND SOCIAL-CRUSADER) OUT , IF HE IS FOUND WAVERING FROM OUR STAND AS WAS EVIDENT FROM HIS UTTERANCES A FEW WEEKS BACK . KAPIL SIBAL WILL DEFINITELY BE BEHIND BARS LIKE A-RAJA . IT IS UNFORTUNATE THAT INSPITE OF HIS BEING SO ARTICULATE AND INTELLIGENT , HE IS NOT ABLE TO SEE THE WRITING ON THE WALL EVEN THOUGH HE KNOWS ABOUT HIS WRONG-DOINGS FULLY WELL . SWAMI ASHEEMANANDJI DIED FOR A GOOD CAUSE OF "GANGES" , BUT 'ANNAJI' WILL NOT DIE WITHOUT HIS VOICE BEING HEARD BY "INDIA" AND THE "WORLD" . THANKS .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vaish, Bombay

    Mon, Jul 18 2011

    My suggestions for the Lokpal bill:

    1. Consider Indian citizens living outside India they are less jaded and will bring a different perspective.

    2. Look into using technology to monitor the Lokpal’s inner activities (as an added deterrent from corruption or favoritism). Example, keep digitized records of every email, landline and cellphone communication on all official devices. These records can be confidential and only accessed in the event of any suspected wrongdoing.

    3. I do believe more thought needs to be put into protecting the Lokpal Chairperson, panel and their families because these people will no doubt become enemy number 1 for a large, ruthless and corrupt swathe of the population who may be willing to resort to murder to protect themselves.

    4. It is worth considering a time period for the Lokpal mandate for say 10yrs or 15 years after which it should be renewed, improved or disbanded based on success and failure.

    5. I do feel VERY strongly about the need to include the Prime Minister and the Judiciary for this to be successful.

    6. Also, all the current vigilance and investigative agencies like the CBI, CVC, etc. should become part of Lokpal or be disbanded.

    7. AND most importantly the Lokpal should look in people’s grievances at every level and not just focus on a few cherry picked high profile cases.

    READ my open letter to India: http://www.vaishwords.com/2011/02/open-letter-to-india.html

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bharat Satpathy, Jamshedpur

    Mon, Jul 18 2011

    Every one must come under Lokpal . No one above law .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • BS Chauhan, Kanpur

    Mon, Jul 18 2011

    Every person who receives salary/money from govt exchequer (centre or state)shoul be brought under the purview of lokpal.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Civil Society Seeks Referendum on PM in Lokpal's Ambit



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.