I Studied in Christian School I am Secular: Advani


Press Trust of India
 
SHILLONG, Sep 20: Seen as the face of hardline Hindutva, senior BJP leader L K Advani on Monday said he was "very much a secular man" and his party stood for  peaceful co-existence of all religious groups.

"I studied in a Christian missionary school and I am very much a secular man," a BJP spokesperson quoted Advani as saying during a close-door meeting he had with religious leaders here.

Representatives from Christian, Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist and tribal organizations participated in the meet that was aimed at clarifying the saffron party's stand on the attacks on Christians, churches and prayer halls in Orissa and Karnataka.

Quoting the BJP leader, BJP MP, Kiren Rijiju said that "religious sentiment should not precede national interest. India is a secular country and no section of the society should be neglected.

"In Orissa, untouchability among the Hindus and a simmering discontent among the lower strata have drawn people to other religions. Social acceptance is a big dilemma there," the BJP leader said.

Chief Minister Donkupar Roy and other Christian leaders expressed anguish over the attacks on Christians in Orissa and Karnataka.

As the church leaders expressed doubts over the governance of BJP, Advani assured that he had asked the chief ministers of Orissa and Karnataka to institute judicial probes into the incidents and bring the culprits to book. 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Michael Lobo, Mangalore

    Fri, Oct 03 2008

    Advani - a shrewd politician who knew how exactly come to power. His weapon is religion. and the way he does is taking the hindu stand and condemning christains and muslims.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • alwyn, mangalore

    Fri, Oct 03 2008

    what a pity! I think daiji has a guiness record for the highest comments for advanis statement, if he really feel that all are speaking against his consience pls for heavens sake go to orissa and be there for a week and then give us a report whether you are secular or those poor suffers safe in this secular country.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ravi, Kuwait

    Fri, Oct 03 2008

    Mr. Advaniji, you should feel ashamed to tell you studied in Christian Missionery School and you are a Secular man. Did you give a single statement when so many Churches, Prayer Halls were attacked, when Nuns,Women & Children were dragged & Laticharged & Tear Gas Shells bursted ? Did you or Sushma or jaitley give any statements ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • rita, mangalore

    Fri, Oct 03 2008

    Good that you said publicly that you studied in Christian school, let the whole world know about it, kindly learn henceforth at least to protcet and safeguard the christian schools and thier other institutions, would you kindly say this in the public too?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • arun, hassan/abudhabi

    Fri, Oct 03 2008

    If the same statement is given by some other leader belonging to any party other than BJP our christian friends would have accepted without comments. Why don't you people treat Mr.Advani as a person rather than a party? When you declare that you are the people of love and peace,Why can't you accept him despite comments.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Merwin,

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Apologies for what? Do you know the pain we are going thorugh?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • R.B.KUNJUR, KUNJUR

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    by reading the comments of christian friends i feel sad.u dont need a mirror for a wound in the hand.95-98%of Indian christians were originally Hindus and they never converted voluntarily.everybody knows what are the rules in a christian school and in a hindu school.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Richard Lobo, Mangalore/Dubai

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    When I read Mr. Advani's Comments and the way Bajrang dal operates (Activities) its all look like double standard game. Need to put an end to this.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan Sequeira, Mangalore

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Just by going to school, you don't become secular. Your parents may be secular and that is why they must have put you to christian school. They also wanted to give you best education. This is another reason you went to christian school not because you are secular. You had no choice then. Did the christian school tried to convert you? Did they ever made you feel, you are from a different religion? ...answer will be always NO. That is the difference between christian and other schools.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Alfred J. Rebello, Kundapur/Dubai

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Long time ago, I commented that L K Advani is a very good 'Break Dancer' and never misses the drum beats. Now it looks like, I was right in commenting so. Now he tells us that he had been educated in a missionary school and therefore he is secular. First he quitely creates the mess and then acting as if he is offering a olive branch, so people believe him. I am sure, if BJP comes back to power in the Centre, we will have havoc all over the country because their first priority is to build the temple in Ayodhya where Babri majid was demolished. And this will bring unrest all over India. The minority community will have to face the worst, if BJP comes to power on its own. Therefore, I hope voters are wise enough so peace will pravail atleast to a certain extent.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shane, mangalore/dxb

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Congrates Advaniji ? Time has changed now people feel your statements are as a comedy joke !! When you reach Pak what you said has not been forgotten yet by we Indians !!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Naveen Pinto, Madanthyaar/ Bangkok

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    All about tripping crap for upcoming elections.. His deliemaa statements may effect to his own party players and shows free way to Congress which mostly believe in future and young people.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Francis, Moodabidri / Sharjah

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    I think some hiding agenda behind this statement of Advani.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Donald Pinto, Chickmaglore/Abu-Dhabi

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Funny statement,, if you are secular, ban your supporting wings.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kiran Adrian tauro, Manglore/Kuwait

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    As per Mr.Rohan Castalino Mr.Telke Advani just crying for votes..its the time to all BJP leaders to show sympathy n regain their seat in Lok Sabha..and Micheal Lobo plz go head with BJP..no issues

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Roland Noronha, Mangalore/Mumbai

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Advani Saab - do not open your mouth wide open. You better go back to your original place Pakistan. You are not an Indian. You have sucked the blood of minoraties along with your colleagues Togadia, Jaswant, Rajnath Singh and last but not the least your BJP Cheer Leader Susma Swaraj.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gerald Salian, Mumbai, Dubai

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    People like Advani is like a dog's tail kept in a tube for months but when you get it out it will still curl, so please do not expect any good things for other communities even the lower cast Hindus, His only wish is to be a PM before he dies and goes to Hell..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jane, mangalore

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Mr. Advani, even if you were studying in christian school, you did not remember anything what was taught in school, as you were busy playing hide and seek with your bajrangi friends once you were back from school.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Isidore, Allahabad

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    Advaniji, I just wonder why you felt like 'proving' your secularism. Is your conscience pricking? Do you feel guilty of the 'communal' activities that you were involved in the past? Let me be frank with you, the mere fact of studying in a Christian school does not prove that you are a secular person. It is your attitude that matters.

    Let your actions be louder than the words. Whom are you trying to fool with your 'secular' card now. Learn to be human. Let not the wrath of God befall on you. I only wish that you remove the coloured glasses from your eyes and be secular in true sense. May God bless you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Richie John Pais, Mangalore

    Thu, Oct 02 2008

    So many comments on this seasoned politician's petty statement? He is as good as Devegowda and Sonia Gandhi. I do not see any difference in them. We have more issues than commenting on a politicians remarks. Inflation is virtually killing people. Karnataka has become the most corrupt state.(Very close to become the most communal).

    These people have made Mangalore the most dusty place by digging them up.And they do not have any answers for our real problems.They have only tried to devide us. An uncultured uneducated thug and criminal suddenly appeared in Mangalore to teach us how to behave. Mangaloreans no matter Hindu Muslim or Christian will always live with harmony. Boycott all the politicians criminals militants..Let Mangalore come back to it's tolerant days.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Louis Dante, Udupi

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    I believe here the question was if Advani gas any opinion on the issues India is faced with today. Communal hatred in Orissa and Mangalore (reported, lot many places are still not reported).. Mr. Advani, Prime Minister Hopeful from the Sangh Parivaar -Safron Party (If the peaceloving BJP/RSS/VHP/Bajarang Dal) is elected to power says He went to christian schools.. the result is...

    1. He has built a good life for himself, like many well groomed leaders, businessmen, politicians, Humble and good men who have really gained good education under strict discipline of the institutions.

    2. He has deprived a different person who would have had an opinion on the issues facing the country (DEMOCRATIC, PEACEFUL INDIA TODAY) For we have not heard any comment on ORISSA AND MANGALORE Violence by His Party - BJP/VHP/RSS/BD....

    3. Was he forced to study Bible in the sclool where he studied or he had separate Moral science or Ethics Classes ? He did not say what he studied in the school, or if he was forced to convert to christianity as HIS party cry foul. He would have helped a more deserving poor child of his time to get ahead in life if he abstained from taking admission in a christian school - because some of his followers suggest exactly that..

    4. Is it a Plea for Minority Vote by trying to identify them and seeking (Begging) minority Vote? People are getting educated and can differentiate Sheep from Volves... Actually minority Vote is not needed if the majority subscribes to the sectarian/communal ideology of the Party Sangh Pativaar with such good Militants in RSS/VHP/Bajarang Dal who waste no time in professing that BJP is their party and they are running the Governments in a,b,c,d states and no one can do anything to them for the Politicians and the government is in their pockets. ( A DEMOCRATIC VIEW OS THE SANG PARIVAAR IDEOLOGY)..

    5. Finally Mr. Advani what is Your honest view on the situation in BJP Ruled states where there is Communal Politics and Murder of Minority and attacks of Prayer Houses. Sure other major topic today is Terrorism..... If the yard stick applies for BJP sponsored ( sangh Parivaar) Bajarang Dal / VHP Terror also ?????

     6. Please do not even repeat what you said

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh, Udupi

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Hello Mr. Siva USA, Do you have any doubt of what you say is wrong or do you want to confirm?? I think time is a healer so we have forgotten the acts and confirmation and proclamation of the Bajarang Dal on Open forums and on stagesthat they did the destruction, they will teach a lesson.

    Who is Togadia? Did he say VIOLENCE WILL BE MET WITH VIOLENCE? Who is going to do violence with him that he has to reply with violence?? Does he need any reason to be violent? Is not his party in power in some states where there are poor people being killed, burnt and the houses of christians and Christian prayer halls being burnt?

    Any need for a reason to create trouble for the Safron Party and the clan that subscribe it it. IT IS OBSERVED THAT TRUE HINDUS, TRUE RELIGIOUS, AND True people of THE GREAT INDIAN DEMOCRACY are only interested in peace. All these people in public who call for attention are interested in taking centre stage in politics.

    Politics is corrupt. Clean people can not create a name in politics. A clean politician unless recognised by the nation and the party and the group he/she is asociated with WILL NOT BE ABLE TO FEED HIM/HERSELF, WILL NOT BE ABLE TO LIVE A PEACEFUL LIFE. It is like a Carpentre whos house has no door because he is busy building other peoples houses. So real and true politician in this time and day can only be recognised and by the good work, propogation of peace and communal harmony they profess.

    All those that run riot are only interested in filling their bank accounts, seek pleasure in other peoples troubles and try and play shahensha, saviour by visiting after the destruction is well over. Does anyone have any doubt that BJP/RSS/VHP ar systematically trying to undo the fabric of civilised society in ORISSA by mass murder, burning innocent people, setting fire to christian homes and prayer halls???

    The human sacrifice is going on for the past 2-3 months and the state government is Directly supporting the criminals. Is it so bad that the State Government machinery can not handle a communal situation in any part of the country? ORISSA... The Mainstream media is with the criminals. There is practically no mention of the crime, murder and human sacrifice in ORISSA in any major TV Channels or News papers.

    The Centre is waiting till the Water goes over their heads?? Is there Democracy In India? The Minorities can be done with as the majority wishes ????? Mr. K.S.Sreeramen ask these questions to yourself and try and find answers in Mangalore, in Orissa, In Meerat and in all those small places where the minorities are really minority and no incidents are reported.

    Sure Donny Lobo, well said, the very people the governments and political parties build up to be used against the opposition come back and haunt and fair enough destroy them who give space to exist. "Chickens come home to roost" Violence can only give rise to violence. ONLY PEACE WILL PREVAIL AT THE END.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • K. S. Mayya, Mangalore/South Korea

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Mr. Edmond Norohna. I like your suggestion (really humorous). It's like all the tamil cars in Bangalore having RajKumar's picture when Veerappan was courting Annavaru. If this is going to happen, I would second it. Advani is famous for tongue in the cheek comments. In many aspects he is right but in many other aspects he is a leader of those followers who will disown him if he does not oblige.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Prakash, India/Dubai

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Its not that just studying in Christian/hindu/Muslim/Buddist instutition one becomes Secular....Secular means all religions have equal rights constitutionally....Most important Freedom to live and let others live........hope Mr.Advaniji admires the meaning of secularism....no wonder India enjoys the pride of being the biggest secular county all over the world....but the price is paid by the innocents.....??? I think communalism is one of the social evil of 21th century....we hope for the better world...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jerome Aranha, Bombay / Dubai

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Hi Advaniji It is established beyond doubt, that you have instigated others to destroy peace and fabric of our secular country for political and selfish gain. At this advanced age, prepare not to gain glory but face God by repenting the sins you have committed during your life.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rohan Castelino, Mangalore/Abu Dhabi

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Nothing more than crocodile tears..Its high time these so called 'religious police' should be branded as terrorist organisations by United States and should be denied the entry into US and EU. The BJP ideology has tarnished India's image and taken India two decades back rather than enhancing its image. 'Who lives by the gun will die by the gun'. Bible has instances where god has turned his rage on his people and i'm not surprised by the turnout of earthquakes and storms in places where people tried to humiliate him.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • clarence miranda, mangalore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Whatever Advani is, let him be. But do not vote for BJP anymore. I agree congress is useless in Karnataka. But BJP is dangerous to ALL.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Michael Lobo, Mangalore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Advani is a nice person. I have all admiraton for for him. He is a able statesman. He can pull country out of danger. I will always vote for BJP

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Walter Miranda , Mangalore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    There is A say in Hindi BELLI HAZAAR CHUHA KAKER HAJ PER GAITHI THI (after eating 1000 rats the cat went to Haj for doing penance) like that after committing so many blunders and brutalities now Advani is declaring that he is studied in the Christian missionary school and he is declaring that he is secular. It is all pure lies Mr. Advani.

    If you were studied in Christian Missionsary school you never would have grown like arogant tiger. According to your name Lal Krishna Advani you are a dangerous man which means you name starts with LAL which means in Hindi red. Do not forget that the red colour is meant for danger.

    You the dangerous man and a dangerous politician and a dangerous leader of the BJP party. I strongly support Mr. Vajapei who is the only good politician joined to a wrong political party of your BJP party. Advani You are solely responsible for destroying the peace in India by breaking the historical monument of Babri mashid by Joining hands with your other Chamchaas Kalyan sinh former CM of uttara Pradesh, Uma Barathi a Safrin lady of India and a highly educated and a qulified man Murali Manohar Johi. Advani you now It is just in the inform sheding the crodile tears in front of the world to gain the confidence of the people over you.

    The ferocious and arogant Tiger now how turned into a pet tiger. If you Advani studied in the Christian school you never grow with arogant character. By commiting a mistake by breaking the Babri Mashid you prove to the world you are a Roudi Hero India. Better you do not dearm to be the next future PM.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Edmond Noronha, Kirem - Mangalore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    It is high time that we make a Saint of Lal Krishna Advani and install in any of the churches to save our places of worship. I am motivated with this article to cannonise Mr. Advani and give him the Mantle, Senior Saints of India. I hope Advani won't ask the resignations of existing saints. Any comments...??

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Mukesh, mangalur

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    I truely agree with Mr.Prasanna these BJP leaders are also foolish.They should concentrate on Nations development,not to concentrate on Vote Bank.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roland , Mangalore/KSA

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Mr. Advani has lost his credibility due to his frequently changing colors.He has a dream to be the next PM(which will be his last opportunity)and at any cost.It is a conspiracy to garner the majority community votes by creating a bogey of insecurity.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nitin, Pangla/B'lore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    I think Mr. Advani don't know the meaning if "secular". Last time when he went to Pakistan he found new AVTHAR of Mr. jinah and gave a contraversial statement. This time he found himself in new AVATHAR!!!. What he thinks, people are fools hear to believe his statements??

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wilfred Crasta, Vittal / Dammam

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    After all the destruction on Churches and Christians Mr. Advanji remembers Christanity and Secularism? Loksabha Elections round the corner. This shows how opportunist he is ! At least come out clean at this old age and correct your destructive attitude towards minorities and then be a Prime Minister of India otherwise, still you will have to wait in a queue...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Maxim Patrao, Mangalore/Dubai

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Mr Advani, all the BJP govts are sponsoring terrorism on christians and muslims. What nonsense are you talking now ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Maxim Patrao, Mangalore/Dubai

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Mr. Advani, your actions speak louder than your words !

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jitendra, Bangalore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Advaniji, no need to prove that you are secular. The present elections will be contested on communal lines.Do you feel catholics have voted for BJP all these years? No.Even Hindus now know who is true secular after the recent church attacks.So be the same. You will be next PM of India

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • lancy, kuwait

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    So atleast Mr.Advani accepted that he is secular but why he is not acting like secular?may be tied with the hindu organisation for votes? the bajarangdal and vhp talking hinduism and religion but they dont know how to treat their own brothers? see in orissa most people ill treated and not allowed to mingle with upper caste also.and these catholic brothers educating them and making their life better so that makes these people jealous as they want the poor people to suffer below them.  So better now open your eyes MR BJP VHP and BAJARANGDAL atleast to treat all equal and then make other religion to follow them.  No use making violence and making crimes, sins and going to hell.the right time has come for you people now.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Melwyn Lobo, Mangalore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    "The Creators of Monsters Die by the Monsters".True to this. Indira Gandhi encourgaed the Sikh movement and Terrorism and died because of this.Rajiv Gandhi Encouraged and discouraged the LTTE and was killed by the later.The LET leaders are born and killed by their own colleagues. Mr.Advanji,you and your colleagues created the fissures in the indian society by your religious sensiting movement.You gained in the short term.

    But you will surely loose in the longterm.Your words seems to come deep from your heart and I feel you might have started repenting.The monsters you created and encouraged are gradually taking over.Dear Advanji the days are not far your creations will take over you and you will be nowhere.No Secularism ,nor religion,no fundamentalism will sustain in the long term.The creator will get destroyed himself.And religion is a very good Opium to do this.Good Luck to all.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Simon, Mangalore / UAE

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    When I read he is secular, I ran for the meaning of the word, but I found none to match his deeds. The tongue is boneless and could be twisted to utter anything to get extract the purpose. Moreover age is catching up so one bound to act like a child. Therefore should anyone believe what he says?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • K. S. Mayya, Mangalore/South Korea

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    The emotional flare-up in the form comments by readers makes me laugh. Since when have we started believing our politicians? For me Advani is as secular as any other Congressi or for that matter Gowda. They are very secular people.

    The word secular means a divided house to these politicians and thier existence is firmly centered around this single word. It has taken such a disproportionate meaning that no Hindu can call himself secular anymore...and Advani is no exception.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vittal, udupi

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    I dont think Mr. Advani is wrong in his statement and he expressed what he is, for this why so much cry ???

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh Kumar, Bangalore

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Hi Naveen Advani is a peace loving person and that's why he love to see the minority in "PIECES"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Einstein H Dsilva, Mangalore/ KSA

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Mr.Advani. Please dont try to fool people by your so called "secularisam"...People are very much aware of your secularisam......

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rahul Desai, Gujrat

    Wed, Oct 01 2008

    Mr K.S.N.Sreeramen, can you enlighten yourself from the current position of a damn fool please??? I reckon you to broaden your knowledge before commenting on any serious issue. I find your comment to be of childish nature. Please go to the site http://www.awaazsaw.org/ibf/index.htm and enlighten your frog knowledge. This website will give you nearly all your answers. May god give you enough knowledge to comment on any serious topic henceforth.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wilson, indian/Dubai

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. K S N Sreeramen, it is not true!!! Ok , Any more Qns?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • WILSON, MANGALORE/DUBAI

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    During 1992 central election he is the main person told that if you need ram mandir give vote to BJP,Now he is telling i am secular man ,his group only attacked churches ,during that time we did not here anything from his good mouth ,where he went that time to protect his goverment?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Praveen, udupi

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Catholic institutions have created many leaders for this country and also to the world. Mr Advani is one among the leaders that catholic institutions has produced. Hope when u become Prime Minister of this country, try to respect catholic institutions and safeguard them from the eveils that your Saffron party is presently undertaking for winning the elections

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Venance A. J. Crasta, Udyavar / Bangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Advani Sir, you are too late.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ashok R. Monteiro, Bahrain/Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Daiji readers pleases dont believe in Advaniji. He is the one main responsible for communal problems throughout India. He promised to build Ram Mandir! On his leadership his followers did Karseva. Now, where is Ram Mandir? Why he is breaking his silence after so many attacks on the Churches and other worship places! Now he is telling I am a Secular Man? Still i remember when he went to PAkistan he praised Mr. Jinna! Mr. Advaniji you are a big opportunist!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • bhaskar, mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr Suresh Amin,are you astrologer?if that your predection will be wrong.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Veerendra,

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. Sharad What nonsense you are writing? First tell your CM to be secular and our arch bishop has every right to protest. Please note we are in a democratic state.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • S.M. Nawaz Kukkikatte, udupi

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Then why you not  become Christian Advaniji ? !!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rolphy Almeida, Udupi/Bangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Dear Siva USA, you are wrong. Just because none of the leaders of those organizations, you have stated came out openly to condemn the attack on Christians, rather tried to justify the attack. Mr. Adwani found today (after 16 days) is the most auspicious day to condemn the attack. Do you have anything to say? Please do not stir up the situation, try to save India, and don’t destroy the peace of this country.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Cyril Monis, Pangla/Riyadh

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Catholics stand for Peace and Harmony and so far I have heard only the good teachings of Jesus Christ from our religious leaders and not a single time preaching against other people. So why this brutality to our brotheren. Is it wise to show brutality to the Catholic holy places,shrines,priests,nuns and common innocent people.I think almost all of us live sorrounded with different beliefs of people in our neighbourhood and we never felt that we are allergic to one another, then why this difference and who is responsible for this to plant this seed of brutality. In a secular country like India where peace is growing and known to be a peaceful country all over the world, why in the name of religion some groups are putting their meaningless effort to spoil this intergrity,peace and harmony.

    Only culprits should be punished or God Himself will take the issue in His hand and judge accordingly. So let us stop blaming one another and think wisely what is right and what is wrong.Studying in Chrtistian Missionery would have inspired good things in ones life and this is right time to implement on this when things are going in wrong direction.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Leo Dmello, Mumbai

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Sharath shetty, why don't you talk sense. Are you truly blind that you can neither see truth or listen to it. So much has happened before your very eyes and yet you behave as if nothing has happened. What has the Arch Bishop that you condemn him.

    Our women have been beaten, our places of worship attacked, our statutes and images torn and smashed and you say our Arch Bishop should behave properly. If we had done the same thing to your temples and smashed your idols of gods, what would be your reaction? You are afraid of conversion because you have little or no faith in your own religion and that is why you feel threatened. Jesus will make you his follower because He loves you and will come to you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shilaja, mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr.Sharath,I do not think that our Archbishop has behaved badly with the Chief Minister.I think that you are an educated man and hopefully understand what is going on.We talk about Central Government not being able to stop terrorism in the country but what about the terrorism in the state of Karnataka which is at the moment under the Bjp government.What do you think of that? Did Karnataka have any problem in the past with regard to religious activities under any other government,then why is it so now? Which Roman Catholic Institution have you come across converting people forcefully? if at all you have come across people getting converted ,it is their own decision and not a forceful conversion.We people still believe in the caste system.

    Certain people are not given certain rights due to which they get attracted to other religions.Do something for the backward castes,then maybe they will not get attracted elsewhere.Probably you are one of those people who will keep quiet when your temples,priests and women are attacked.We are all humans and over the years we have borne everything silently but not when the Cross has been destroyed,our nuns are attacked and the Blessed Sacrament is attacked.Remember that we are all Indians,not foreigners.It's just that we are born into different families of different religions.If you were born a Catholic,today you would have thought differently and you too would not have tolerated all this.This is all politics but in the bargain it is the common man who is suffering.It does not make sense for us to fight against one another.Instead let us all be united so that no foreign country can take advantage of us.Advani is actually from Pakistan.He is bent upon dividing India on the basis of Religion and there are a few sadist people who support him.

     If the people of India are united we can throw out people like these who want to divide our country.Let him do something good in his old age rather than doing bad and being cursed by the people which will affect him and his family.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • donfrank, mangalore, UAE

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. LK Advani is a big liar. His words are like 'a devil quoting the scriptures". Unfortunately, some educated Hindus have fallen into his trap and raise the issue of "conversions". Mr. LK Advani is dreaming to become the PM of this great country. In order to justify the brutal attacks on Christians, he and his bunch of fanatics are giving contraditory statements. The whole world knows that it was Mr. LK Advani who was responsible for the terrorism in the country. He spearheaded the destruction of Babri Masjid and the voilence against Muslims in India. Everyone knows how he gave a clean chit to that dreaded butcher of Muslims, Mr. Narendra Modi, after the infamous anti-Muslim voilence. I call upon all the Hindus to defeat the communal/fanatic forces represented by Mr. Advani Let us live in peace and harmony. Le us remember one thing. Millions of Hindus are living outside India and practice their religion without any problem. They even convert people in thousands. No one is doing them any harm. Their temples are not attacked. Let us live in peace and harmony. Let us be united in defeating the communal forces.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Antony, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    What Sharad Shetty talks is senseless. Hindus are attacking ruthlesssly and here our shetty says behave properly. I think he should first come to the senses of what he is talking about. if his house is attacked, should he keep behaving properly.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • clarence miranda, mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    K.S.N.Sreeramen, 1. It is true that you DO NOT know our Constitution and our Fundamental Rights. 2. It is is true that the Bhajrangis, Sangh, VHP etc entered and attacked our holy places. 3. It is true that police beat up women, religious nuns and innocent people. 4. It is true that police arrested our innocent christian youth. 5. It is true that the home minister and CM supported these unlawfull activities. 6. It is true that home minister & CM did not take any action on these culprits. Now you can learn and ADD more to this list.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Das, UAE

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Dear Ramen, Yr Questions seem to be non sensical? Is it not that grant from foreign missions comes to Hindu Charitable trusts? What happens to same? Is it used for welfare purposes or just for selfish celebrations? You need to first answer these questions. One imp Q's why is it that when elections are nearing there are bomb blasts and riots, is BJP sponsored to deflect attention of voters.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harsha Canute, Kuwait

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. Advani you are the founder of militant groups in India by demolishing Babri Masjid. Same like America created Taliban. The whole nation witness for this. Now dont try to become secular for the election, your own people so called hindu terrorist will kick you out. You studied in Christian school it dosent mean that you are secular. Some bajranji who attacked on church also studied in in Christian school. You are hiding that all you are doing for the vote.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rakesh, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. K S N Sreeramen, it is not true!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Arulraj, Madras

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr.Advani, what you talked is a big lie. God alone knows the truth of yours. I don't think you can give peace to India and its people.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • sharath shetty, padubidre

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    stop supporting newlife type of institutes.. and even conversions...then we can seek apology from BJP. Also ask your archbishop to behave properly with the chief minister.....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • STANY, MANGALORE

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    I Have no respect for this Pak double agent, he is just practice the religion of hate.He is the man who started destruction in India.I am sure he will pay from his life but still he will burn in hell.He wants to become PM at any cost. A TRUE SINDI MANU.can not be trusted

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ROBERT. C MATHIAS., KANYANA,PILAR, MUDARANGADI, KENHA PARISH, AT MULUND MUMBAI.

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    ADVANIJI, NAMASTE AUR AAP KO PRANAM. ESAYEE YONKU HATYA KARNE KA AADESH KISNE DIYA/? BAJRANGIYOO NEY KYA/? AAP BOLTHE AAP SECULAR HAY? When your govt. was there in powerr Australian Missionery Rev. Graham Stain was burnt alive with his two teen aged sons? what was your partys led by sri. murli mahohar joshi, promod mahajan,.and NDA convenor, when they visited Orissa, at that time there was a foreign hand in the killing. Bajrang dal member and BJP meber Dara singh burnt alive these innocent people. where was secularism of you and your party?

    If your party comes to power in the next elections, it will be because of massacre of christians in BJP BJD rules states. But it will never survive. IF BJP aand Bajrangis, want to continue to kill christians and destroy the HOLY SACRED HOLY COMMUNION. WHERE is your secularizm?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • LOBO,

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    You dont know what you are talking about

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vincy, shamboor/Bangkok

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Kal Ho Na Ho. say what ever you can say now.Why you did not say that your family members are also converted christians.why you want to hide the reality.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Anil Fernandes, Madanthyar/Bangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Advaniji, Apka Natak Bandh Karo. All Secular people who think of the welfare of the state and country will teach you lesson this time. When election is nearby, you realise that you are a secular man and India is a secular country otherwise even you and your party forgets that there is a right to religion to all the citizens of India that is stressed in the Article of the Constitution.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh Kumar, Bangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Hi,Advani cha cha India is a better place to live without you and your associates like BJP,RSS,VHP,Bajrang,etc. Only then we will sing "Zarai Jaahe se acha hindustan hamra"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • clifford, bejai / dubai

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    A Fascist and a blatant Liar.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rolphy Almeida, Udupi/Bangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    At last he gathered his guts to condemn the attack on Christians. He thought that Shillong is the right place to do that after consulting his astrologers and assessing the poor support of Hindu intellectuals. What made him to delay in making a decision, who once called Dr. Manmohan singh nikhamma? Is it true that he failed miserably in his strategy, for the parliamentary election hatched during Bangalore convention? How he remained a Hindu after studying in a Christian school? Nobody induced him to become a Christian? Why some people cannot understand that when the pressure builds up from foreign land, these politicians disown the groups who work for them and condemn their activities. Wake up dear brothers, we are Indians first, then comes our religion. We all love to see India prospering, so please don’t destroy this lovely country.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • juliet tauro, Bombay

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Had he and his cronies not demolished babri masjid we would not have faced bomb blast in India. Same thing applies to George Bush. Had he and father not attacked Iraq there would'nt have 9/11. That sums up everything.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Usha, Manglore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. Advani, don't fool us OK? Don`t play too much OK? Behave as a senior HUMAN BEING.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dony Roche, Mangalore/Jeppu.

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr.Dony Lobo, your comment on thi s topic gives correct picture of Advani . What you say is true and correct. I met you in K.C.A. Hostel Mumbaifew years back. I like to read your comments on various topics. Keep it up.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • E. Saldanha, Kadri

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Advani expects people to believe him! It is sad that he received education in a Christian Missionery school. Had he been a good student things would not have been so murky. I simply wonder what he studied in that school. In politics one can say mountains of lies and can still wear a smile. This is going on at present. Many of our political leaders are blatent examples. God grant them light. E. Saldanha.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • K.S.N.Sreeramen, CHENNAI

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr.Advaniji

    1.Is not true Christian are involved in conversion ?

    2.Is not true that Foriegn Fund reach indian christian missions. ?

    3.Is not true that only lower strata of community are lured for conversion ?

    4.Is not true no affluent get converted ?

    5.Is not true that Money can be only reason for conversion ?

    6.Is not true that not only majority community even BJP is branded as non secular and such reasons are promoted to JUSTIFY BOMB BLASTS.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gilroy, Mangaluru

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    BJP and Secularism is like water and oil. Mr. Adavni apologize for your Rath Yathra (or vote yathra). Severe your party's connection with RSS, Bhajrang Dal, VHP etc.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rupert, Canada/Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr.Advani is a wolf in sheep clothing, the number one hypocrite, a Indian Gestapo. What has he done to stop violence against christians and their institutions in Orissa, Karnataka, M.P., Kerala etc. Advani, stop your "Naataka" and come out with your true colours. Are you not the same person who aileanated the muslim brothers, by your naataka on Babrimasjid,and ratyatra, a consequence of which the country paying. Don't come with the crap that you were educated in a christian institution, the same one your followers are destroying. JAI-HIND, JAI BHARATMAATHA.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Siva, usa

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    there are so many comments here which say BJP Govt is oppressing minorities and is involved in attacking chruches etc.!! How can people who swear in the name of truth tell such things without verification? Have you seen any BJP/RSS leader indulging in voilence in attck of church? Have you seen any of their leaders providing instructions to do this? or do you have even information (or even just hearsay) that the attack was preplanned before the 'SathyaDarshini' was published. More importantly nothing was known to the political leaders. Why do you guys want to tell lies and repeat it? If you are speculating that RSS leaders did this, I can also speculate that it was Congress which did this as operation Hand a relatiation for operation Kamala!! I can also speculate that SIMI created this plot to create a huge wedge between Hindus and Christians in Coastal Karnatka to further their interests. How can you say what I say is wrong - just because it is not according to your opinion - what I say is wrong?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Naveen, Bejai

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Advaniji is a peace loving person and is the future of India. May God be with him and give him more power to be a good leader as he is currently is. BJP will eradicate out terrorism and Advani will prove it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Antony T. D' Souza, Karkala, Doha-Qatar

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    “I am a secular man” showing his chameleon colour after almost 15 days !. However, it is not be surprised that by the end of the day those people will shed that image hundred times !. Until and Unless BD, SP etc., had the blessings of the senior political political leaders and Policemen (we have witnessed the brutality of lathi charging, nuns and women inside the church itself !) in Orissa or Karnataka such a master plan of systematic mass scale attacks on Christians and their Prayer places is unimaginable covering such a different areas in a short time and within no time !. Therefore, a real, true, honest, sincere, objective and secular minded Hindu will never vote for him and his party. Then where is the opportunity for him to claim the PM seat ? However at this juncture, we and I should not forget to thank every majority Hindu brother with whom we intermingled and came across in our life who are really peace loving, encouraging co-existence and are truly secular who are really jewels in our Hindu Nation. Therefore, it is worth ignoring a minority few who boast themselves that “I or we are secular men” after violating and crossing all border lines of fundamentals of divine secular principles.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Suresh Amin, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Shahnawaz k, UAE, Adavaiji is the next PM of India and mark my word. Just think of how the terrorism will be eradicated out of the country and not Advaniji.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • A.S.Mathew, U.S.A.

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. Advani is a classical politician, who can talk with three tongues at the same time to please the friends, enemies and the rest. He took the initiative to destroy the Babri Masjid and started a river of blood, thousands of people had to suffer, but he was safe all the time. Then he went to Pakistan and praised Mr. Jinnah as a great person.

    He made repeated statements that Christians must leave India and land in the Western countries like the U.S.A. He had been to Kerala to preside over a function of the Marthoma Church. If invited to participate, he has the gut to attend a Christian Church and participate the Lord's supper or mass. But, he will play the ploy behind to undermine the minorities that is the nature of Mr. Adavani. India has a battalion of professional politicians, out them, Mr. Advanji is the top ranking.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan Pais, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Here is a spineless man who talks about secularism.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peter , Udupi / Kuwait

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Advani will demolish india after he become PM,these are the people only Who killed Ghandhiji and now talking about peace and ahimsa,they are big drama people. Advani is the reason for current terrorist attacks in india. Today we have a PM who is honest and one of the most qualified individiuals.

    His drawback is that is oratory is not good like Vajpayee & Advani and his remarks do not have punches against anyone. He is soft spoken and a thorough gentlemen. Today BJP does not envy him because they know he is presiding over the nation during tough times.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Danny D'souza, Mumbai / Kuwait

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr. Advani Please dont forget your political career began when you joined the RSS in 1942. Then became the secretary of the organization's Karachi branch. In 1947, You were sent to Mewat in Rajasthan, where you witnessed communal violence following partition, to oversea the affairs of the Sangh.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • DONY LOBO, KELARAI, MILAGRES, DOHA, QATAR

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    “I Studied in Christian School I am Secular:” Advani Studied What….??? To destroy prayer houses…??? To make helpless members of minorities to shed blood….? To look the other way when Staines was burnt to death or when Gujerath was burning…? Or swap a dreaded terrorist for the Indian Airline’s hijacked plane…? Or studied to question the credibility of Sonia Gandhi’s marriage to Rajiv and brand her as a foreigner all through the last general elections…or to organize Rath Yathra to sow the seeds of communal hatred all along enroute. It looks like Mayawati’s emergence as a Prime Ministerial candidate should the opposition win the next elections …. Has send jitters down the spine of this old man.

    All these years we had respected this man as a man of steel nerves or a modern day Vallabhbai Patel ….but now he reminds us of a medieval Tuglak. U.S.A encouraged and supported Bin Laden & co. in the war against the Soviets and ultimately are still paying the price for the same since 9/11. Indiraji encouraged Bindranwale and ultimately it is his followers who nailed her. Advani saab, unless you go down on your knees and apologise to God and break away completely from those who Broke the Arm of Jesus on the Cross and those who injured the helpless Nuns and Women of Mangalore……not only you will never never have peace for the rest of your life but these very people whom you have groomed....will ultimately finish you off in style.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ronald. S., Barkur/Udupi

    Tue, Sep 30 2008

    Mr Advani has lost numerous opportunities at (mis)representing himself, so much so that even if, on a future date, he decides to reveal who he is and what he really stands for, no one would be able to believe him ! Poor man !!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Steven, kuwait

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr. Advani, it is only because of you communal violence has started and it is spreading like fire.The moment you started the demolition of babri masjid India's image has changed. Though you have enough work to do in Delhi,your frequent visits to mangalore over these years are yielding now. Indians will not elect you as Prime Minister. By mistake if you become the Prime Minister of India I am sure India and also Indians will be banned world over for the things you are teaching, preaching and practicing now.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vishal, India

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Advanji why r u not yet convert?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ahmed Nisar, mangalore/dammam

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr Advani we all secular Indians know how secular you are after your secular rathyathra India become more secular.Thanks to you and your Sanghparivar

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • sahil, Mangalore /Dubai

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Hope he knows the meaning of secular. no wonder he is a poet.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • V.D'Souza., Udupi / Doha-Qatar.

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Dear. Santhosh,We don't need Mr.Advani's MALHAM to our christian brothers' wounds as you said. You better help him to apply that over his tongue. So that tomorrow he can tell "I studied in chritian school,I'm secular and also I'm CHRITIAN". Advaniji, please don't shed crocodile tears. We know your true colour.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Daniel Davis, Dubai

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Such people should be shown the door to self exile centers.We have seen a similar character from across the border and what harm he caused to his country and world & we all know where he is destined to. May God Bless him with his peace .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dennis Menezes, Jeddah,Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr. Advani, It is like saying “Holier are than thou” Where were you when the Christians were attacked and their worship places were desecrated.? When you came to Bangalore for the BJP convention event, you never spoke a single word against the atrocities done by your cadres of Bajrangdal and in fact went on encouraging you CM to talk on conversion. A good tree is known by its fruit it bears: you don’t gather figs form thorns, or grapes from brambles. Similarly a hypocrite person draws evil things from the evil stored in his heart. With out your consent no one dares to attack Christians as the whole world knows the contribution of Christian community to the nation as law abiding and humble citizens.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • William D Souza, Kallianpur, Abu Dhabi

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Good gimmick Mr. Advani. This is election time. You are in a hurry. Age is catching up. We can understand your problem "Kal Ho na Ho !"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wilson, Indian/dubai

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Why do you commenting against Mr.Advani? May be he wants to change his past life style and n be a secular man n wanted to help man kind, lets give him one more chance !

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Michael Andrade, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr. Advani, I was happy to read the headline and was about to vote for you until I saw the comments below. Better luck next time.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Walter Saldanha, mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Thank God Advaniji, those missionaries did not convert you, baap re baap! Lekin aap aur secular........... yeh baat hazam nahin ho rahi hai. bharat ka baccha baccha janta hai.......ki..aap secular hote to itni dharmik himsa ho rahi hai aur aap maun vrit dharan kiye huye hain.Oh, this is a peculiar secular.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • clifford Fernandes, uk

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    This must be a misprint!. Why meet religious leaders behind closed doors?. Is he afraid that his cronies will take note of what he says.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • A.D'Cunha Shenoy, Mangaluru

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr. Advani, your statement sounds hypocritical. On the one hand you say you studied in the Christan missionary school and on the other your party affiliates attck Churches and innocent and peace loving Catholics. Where is your public statement condemning Bajrang dal and VHP etc, when bajrang dal claimed responsibilty for the atatcks? and where are you, did you even attempt to visit these vandalised holy places. Any one can comment but it takes courage and guts to come out and admit your party affiliates actions. Are you asking for Christians/Catholics votes? or are you serious? If you are serious in what you say, warn the Bajrangis openly throug the media and also consider a ban on the outfit. What do you say Mr. Advani?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jane, Managalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr Advani you are truely and opportunist. We don't trust you as always! You are trying to be nice but it is not what you mean.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • CANUTE, MLORE, DUBAI

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr Advani If u are a Secular man, then tell ur associate organisation's like RSS, BD, Ram sene, VHP,etc to shutup and mind their business.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shaun, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Let me tell you one thing Mr. Advani by studying in a christian school it certainly does'nt guarantee that a person has developed secular qualities. Where was your secularism when your insane party activists demolished the Babri masjid and you were seen sitting on a dais and applauding.where was your secularism when your parties terror outfits went on a rampage in Orissa & Karnataka? And lastly where was your INDIAN patriotism when you went and sang praises of Mohammed Ali Jinnah in YOUR 'JANAM BHOOMI'PAKISTAN?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • joseph Ajman, karnataka

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr.Advani anyone tried to convert you in Christian School?if not testify.......?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peter , Udupi / Kuwait

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr. ADavani one more dialgoue is still left. just announce "RAM MANDIR KA HAL ELECTION KE 3 MAHINE KE BAD NIKAL AYEIGA" so all the religion will happy.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • VINOD WIFLRED TAURO, MADANTHYAR,DUBAI

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Big opportunist, Advani is passing comments at a rightime..statements looks typical like George Fernandes...May be due to old age !!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • C. Mendonca, Mangalore/USA

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    keep your mahlam for yourself mr. Santosh. When your people get injuries dont forget to rub them

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joachim Fernandes, US

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    If India was a secular country, Hindu politicians involved in breaking mosques and vandalizing churches would be in prison. They would not be in parliament making speeches.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Lancelot N. Tauro, Manglore - Doha qatar

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr. Advani we know that you born in Pakistan, studied in St.Patrick School in Karachi. Nobody has asked you this question? Don't dream about getting votes for this type of jokes for the next lokasabha election.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Victor Simon D'souza, Belman/Dubai

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Respected H.E.Mr Advani I don't think you are interested with all the recent incident,your comments look like begging vote from the Minorites because all we know you and your Hindutva.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gopal, UK

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Dear Mr.Advani, Do not try to be nice. YOU CAN NOT BE A GOOD PRIME MINISTER OF SECULAR INDIA.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Khursheed Hussain, Abu Dhabi

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Advaniji, your statement does not match to your personality. In fact the religious leaders met you in closed doors are fools.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Maxim rosario, Valencia

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    It takes no time to understand the hypocracy of Advani. If he was secular where was he during the attacks on christians in Orissa and Karnataka in particular? God forbid that man to utter like this.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Prasanna,

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Guys I find the comments here amusing. So what would Advani gain by making this statement?Either ways Christians and Muslims en-bloc vote on communal lines for Congress or any of the self-professed secular parties election after election If Advani was looking for electoral gains he would rather make a provocative remark aimed at mobilising the majority voters.Instead he makes a statement that is sure to invoke the ire of even his own party faithfuls Instead of going by the media created demonic image,try to understand the complex personality of Advani.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan D'costa, Moodbidri/Abudhabi

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Did u get convert Mr.Advani eventhough you studeid in a christian school?.Some of your party people spreading the hatred towards catholics. Can you just call upon RSS,BD,VHP brigades to stop this forever! If your a true secualr man!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajith, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    What a joke?.In Advani's world black is white and vice versa.Fandamentalists are secular and seculars are pseudosecular.For 60 years Sanghparivar tried to come to power.Only once they succeded and blew up their chance of governing India due to their sectarian politics.Advanis lifetime dream of becoming PM will not come true,thanks to the organisation he belongs to.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Aldrin, Goa

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Dear H.E.Advani, Thank you for your comments. It has been proved during recent crisis attack on minority Christians, you and your party has demonstrated your qualities. Instead of your comments you should have visited states and assured your governments support to minority and repair the damage caused by your party workers. You have brought international attention. Even most governments in the middle east and western world are concerned about your lack of control on such destruction and killings of innocent people. If you do not show material sympathy we will never forget you and will do everything to withdraw support to your party. Even learned Hindus, Muslims and other caste leaders are much disturbed with these riots.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ronald, Bijai/Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Dear LK Advani! have you forgotton What statement you gave in your Pakistan Visit and all BJP revolted agaionst you!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Richard Rego, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Studying in a Christian school does not make Advani a secular person, just as it did not make Uma Bharti any better human being. Therefore, for Advani to tell he is a secularist is to call a fox honest.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajith, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr. Advani,We are not fools.You tried Mandir agenda and failed.Now conversion agenda.You will fail again because people in general in India are secular but you and your bandwagon are not.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • R Prabhu, IXE/KSA

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    What else can a politician say at the end of the road. The magical chair of PM has not been destined for LKA. It is after his historic visit to Karnataka which concluded on 13th Sept. all the trouble began.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • vikson godwin, ABUDHABI

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    wel don advani, u very nice talking.u realy BJP

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Simon Lasrado, Bengaluru

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    By wearing green showl,and taking the oath in the name of farmer on the oath taking ceremony,Yeddy can not be concidered as true farmer.By studying in christian school how can Advani be called as secular? Might be Bin Laden also studied in Christian school.Can we call him true citizen? Secularism is in the form of behavior not show off like Yeddy and Advani..India must have proud of such communual people.!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jacintha, mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr.Advani is inconsistent. Drop his comments like hot potato. He started poll-compaign through this statement. If he is secular, and he wants us to believe him, he should quit BJP, which is aligned with Hindu Fundamentalists. Challenge Mr. Advani?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Prakash, Kasaragod

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    I was ashamed to know that Mr. Advani is a product of Chirstian institution. A fundamentalist like Advani should not have come out of a Christian Institution. And you have no any concern for the Christians and other minorities, even though you gained your education in their institutions!. The education has not moulded your life.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jerald coutinho, suratkal/bangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Mr.Advani's Statement indicates that the elctions are nearing!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harold D'cunha, Mangalore, India

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Dear Santosh we donot want MAHLAL to our injuries. What we want is justice for the injustice done to us. We want apology from BJP leaders.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • clarence miranda, mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    I Studied in Christian School is TRUE. I am Secular is FALSE. Nice Quiz Mr. Advani. This quiz is easy to solve.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Santosh, Udupi / Bahrain

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Very well spoken Mr.Advani. This is the true BJP. Atleast you have rubbed some MALHAM to the injuries of the christian brothers. Well done. I hope others in your party will follow you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joseph Mendonca, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Please abide by yourword,if you are secular please interfere those states where BJP is ruling to stop the violence and persecution against christians especially Orissa and Karnataka

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • bhaskar, mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    It is all political gimmicks.politicians are trying their best to secure a votebank in coming elections.they are trying best heel the pains which are given by them only.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Don, Katapady

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Don't shed crocodile tears of secularism Mr.Advani!!You played the card of religion to come to power. Dont forget that!not only you most of the prominet personalities of this country have come out of christian institues. Advise your goondas not to indulge in hurting christians. They are peace loving people. Play the game of development politics, Im with you & not the religious politics. We need a better living condition Mr. Advani & not the religious devide

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shahnawaz k, dubai/udupi

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    "I am a secular man - Advani" is the biggest joke of the century. If he is secular, he would not have organised the destruction of Babri Masjid. He should say "I am an opportunist" When he went to Pakistan he was praising Jinnah and when he is in India, he is critical of Jinnah. Mr Advani, you will never become the PM of India, but you have every right to dream of it. Go on dreaming. Good luck.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ahmed Ali, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Advaniji... Election is closer. So you better know how to play the cards. Last time to gain power in central, Your party played the same tricks with Hindu brothers that BJP will build Ram temple in Ayodya. This time you are convincing minority to gain power in central. "CROCODILE TEARS". If you are a real secular man then please put pressure with your team to ban RSS, Bajrangdal, VHP as you know well that these anti social elements are the main root cause of spreading communal violence in India. I am sure that you will never agree with me as you are also a member of the above. Advaniji... Please dont shed crocodile tears.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Noel Frank, Magalore,- KSA

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    There is a saying "Time is the greatest healer". Time has healed even a person like Mr. Advani. He is no more the old religious hard liner or hindutva fanatic. I dont know how much influence he has on the other saffron leaders to make them accept his present day thinking of secularism

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harold D'cunha, Mangalore, India

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Very glad to hear that Mr. Advani had expressed that he is the product from Christian missionary school. Mr. Advani please advises us whether you have been forced to change your religion as there is big cry in Karnataka that there is forceful conversion. Will you please advise your Sangh Parivar not to spread poison in the mind of Hindus against Christians as we have lived till this time in harmony and as one community? Today you are a national leader. Whatever leadership you have learnt isn’t because of the good education imparted by the missionary? Your BJP government in Karnataka has already hurt the feelings of Christians with their biased attitude towards minority. This truth nobody can deny it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • wilma, kundapur

    Mon, Sep 29 2008

    Is Mr.Advani spoke to pasify the christians or to save his name as a sinior BJP leader?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: I Studied in Christian School I am Secular: Advani



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.