Mangalore: Home Stay Attack - Families of Four Accused Claim Innocence, Seek Justice

@ Asha, Padil/ Nagori,

WHEN TWIN TOWERS WAS BOMBED BIN LADIN WAS NOT IN NEW YORK.
- I didn't know these guys had something to do with world trade center. I don't see a point here.

THE POLICE ARE INVESTIGATING AND THEY WILL FILE ONLY IF THEY HAVE EVIDENCE
- Read my post. Police do not have any evidence against them. The only reason they're not being released is that there is strong public opinion against releasing anyone arrested for this incident - even if they are innocent.

IF YOU ARE SO INTERESTED IN BOTH THESE GOONS OR ARE RELATED TO THEM THEM WHY DON'T YOU COME DOWN AND STAND BAIL.?
- First of all these are not goons. You don't know them, so don't assume. Secondly, we've had 3 bail hearings so far and they were all rejected.

MR . PREM PATRAO

WHEN TWIN TOWERS WAS BOMBED BIN LADIN WAS NOT IN NEW YORK.

THE POLICE ARE INVESTIGATING AND THEY WILL FILE ONLY IF THEY HAVE EVIDENCE

IF YOU ARE SO INTERESTED IN BOTH THESE GOONS OR ARE RELATED TO THEM THEM WHY DON'T YOU COME DOWN AND STAND BAIL.?

Last time justice was lacking. This time justice must be met. A landmark judgement is what I am looking forward to. The accused must be severely punished. Female beating, moral policing NO, NO, NO.

I don't know all four of them, but I do know 2 of them very well. I grew up in Padil and have known Tharanath Alva (a.k.a Thanu) and Venugopal (a.k.a Venu) for 30 years now. I can vouch for their secular credentials. They are not part of any communal organizations, in fact quite the contrary. They are respectable family men, who are caught in the political cross fire. This is my opinion of them, you don’t need to agree with me, but let’s look at some facts to quell some of the questions the readers are posing:

1. If they were innocent, why were they in the video of the incident : They heard about the attack and came to the scene after the police arrived. Their faces are seen in the video briefly when the police are around. There is no video of them attacking any of them – simply because they were not there when the attacks happened. They were arrested by the cops the next morning from their homes.
2. Why has it taken their families so long to claim their innocence : Their families and friends started working on their release the very day they were arrested. They’ve met police officials and political leaders on a number of occasions to implore for their release – just by looking at the facts around their arrest. They’ve were given a patient hearing and told that if they’re innocent, they will be cleared of all wrong doing when all facts are established. The families allowed for the legal proceedings to complete, but now after 3 bail petitions being rejected, they have taken to the media.

While it’s understandable as to why they were picked up initially, it doesn’t make sense to still keep them locked up after 5 weeks. There is no evidence of their involvement in the incident. While what happened at Morning Mist was deplorable, keeping the innocent locked up is not the solution.

My sincere advice to all the ABVP or NSUI young students don’t spoil your life by indulging in scufflesm, goonda gardi and fist fight. Remember once again attack on morning mist doesn’t give twist, the judge is refusing to release HJV goondas from jail not even on bail. The families of four moving from pillar to post submitting petitions and their running was waste still they are in a haste to release but everything is in vain.

Jaggu, You are a youth of Mangalore but you lack knowledge and history of Mangalore.
Mangalore was very fashionable from 4 decades. Mangalore has produced Mr. World, Ms. World, Actors, Actresses and Athlelts.
Who told you how to celebrate the birthday by giving sweets to the mouth? That is only for KG children. College students celebrate in different ways and they are grown up and educated, India belongs to them.
Live and let others live. Do not interfere or meddle in other peoples celebrations. Perhaps you do not know how many religions, how many festivals and what kind of fashion exists in India?
We want our Mangalore to be a safe heaven for our future generation.
Jai Hind.

These are no different from the Parents of the Terror accused ! Prabhakar Bhat has set up this scheme to garner sympathy. Dear Parents please look after your children Spend time with them Do not outsource parenting to workers.

AMMA
THIS WOULD NOT HAVE
HAPPENED IF YOU TAUGHT
THEM TO "
" STAY AT HOME"
INSTEAD OF GOING TO
"HOME STAY "

Agreed with Shanawaz Sir,
Innocent Indvidual should not be harmed except those two goons Subhash & Ganesh.

Guys who ever writing against to this innocent statement you don't know the truth, yes as far as I know it is true that Tharanath Alva and Venugopal are innocent, they never involved with any immoral activities in the past, in fact Tharanath Alva is involved in social work and Venugopal is a poor chap who is a Rickshaw driver. They were spectators it was their bad luck police caught them. So please guys everything you read in the paper cannot be correct nor what you see in the TV. Please if you don’t know at least don’t narrate bad comments.

ha what a joke! at that time in that place what they had to spectate? those who are behind bars were supposed to be with the family at home with wife and children what they were doing in that place. if they were not behind bars these same ladies would have been proud of happy of these rouges. they must be behind bars till they realize the evil power of their dirty minds. you should kick out of you homes these guys ladies.

ಆ ಪುಂಡರಿಗೆ ಆಟ.. ಅವರನ್ನು ನಂಬಿದ ಕುಟುಂಬಕ್ಕೆ ಪ್ರಾಣ ಸಂಕಟ ... HJV ಕಾರ್ಯಕರ್ತರೆ ನೀವು ಇನ್ನು ಮುಷ್ಕರ ಮಾಡಿ ತಪ್ಪನ್ನು ಮರೆ ಮಾಚಲು ಪ್ರಯತ್ನಿಸುವುದನ್ನು ಬಿಟ್ಟು ಈ ನೊಂದ ಕುಟುಂಬಕ್ಕೆ ಸಹಾಯ ಮಾಡಿ..

If the have sisters, mother & wife, why they beaten other girls. Bail should not be granted these people and the should booked under terrorist case.

Today Its'a private party tommorrow it may be your own house? No dancing, no laughing, no celebration?
innocense and ignorance are not an excuse under law

If they were punished for church attack, pub attack they would not have experienced these days. BJP and Police helped these people at that time, but, now God is punishing them.

HOW SAD.. THESE HJV GUYS LEAVE THEIR WIVES AND GO TO MOLEST CHILDREN. WHAT A EVIL TO SOCIETY. THEY SHOULD BE PUNISHED OTHERWISE GENERAL PUBLIC WILL CONSIDER MOLEST AND RAPE TO BE INDIAN CULTURE.. DONT LET THEM FREE. PUNISH THEM FOR THE WRONG THEY DID.

If the accused whose video footage clearly says everything and still if they are innocent the court will decide. Who are behind getting these Sangh Parivar ladies to Mangalore Press Club to misuse the media forum?

Poor family members does not known what thier husband and childrens did in home stay that day, by seeing those vidieo clipings any body can make out what type cruelity they did on those innocent girls and boys that day. who ever they may be put them in goonda act if they proved guility.Next time they will think hundred times before acting.

If these women had taugh thier men Indian culture this situation would not come to try to save culprits.HJV may help you , ask them to provide you daily meals because they have taken your men away from you and taken away your bread and butter.

DEAR PARENTS,
DONT WORRY YOUR SON OR HUSBAND WILL COME VERY SOON. LET THE LEGAL PROCEDURE START. WILL SEE WHO THE VICTIM GIRL ARE. THEY STILL HIDING. COURT WILL DECIDE WHAT TYPE OF BDAY IS? AND VICTIMS ALSO HAD TO ANSWER LOT OF QUESTIONS. SO FAR ONLY TWO VICTIMS CAME OUT. THIS CASE IS VERY WEAK IN COURT. AND YOUR LAWYER IS VERY CLEVER. HJV, HINDU YUVASENA, BHAJRANGDAL, ETC ALL ARE FULLY SUPPORTING YOU. ONLY ONE OR TWO WILL GET PUNISHMENT.REST OF THEM WILL COME OUT VERY SOON.THIS CASE IN BETWEEN RICH AND THE POOR. RICH PEOPLE DONT WANT SHOW THEIR DAUGHTERS FACE IN PUBLIC IN THEASE TYPE OF CASE AND POOR PEOPLE READY TO FACE ANYTHING

Parents,spouse& siblings ultimately suffer.Its sad a sole bread winner has to be behind the bars for being a spectator of this incident.They should approach Bajrang Dal,HJV or similar org for help & explain thier difficulties so they realise others greviences as well.Problems faced by this poor famlies is nothing but because of such org.

Every one here in the form are innocent. Till then they are under custody as SUSPECTS. Married guys with family at home going for anti social activities not advisble.
Now they come to know KANOON (LAW) IS TIGHT.

All parents will tell about their childrens are innocent. but when child was young , they are not teaching their child about the manners, its responsibility of a parent that they have to send their children for moral science class. Specially giving respect, for human being, teach them for a family value. now if you say my son is innocent or my husband is innocent. For present situvation you are the one people are responsible for this. let it be, you parents made misstake, now this correct time god will punish them, BZ god knw eveything, may be your son or husband is creating story but GOD knw eveything . leave it for a god.

JAGGU.. WE DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU MEAN TO SAY.
SHAME THAT YOU FAMILY PEOPLE COME FRONT TO SAVE YOUR DEAR ONCEA AND THAT TO IN THE MEDIA. START HATRED TO YOUR DEAR ONCE'S AND THAT TIME THEY WILL COME TO KNOW THEIR MISTAKE.

IF YOU NEED JUSTICE PLZ CONTACT HJV CHIEF OR PRAMOD MUTALIK

YOU ARE THE ONCE'S WHO HAVE SUPPORTED YOUR CHILDREN TO GO IN A WRONG WAY.

THINK IF YOU PARENTS WERE IN THE PLACE OF GIRLS WHO WERE MOLESTED??

@ Sundesh Pinto why the parents of the victims come forward the police is already taken action on the culprits. These goondas ventured to a premises without permission and did the bad act. May some wisdom prevail in you to analyze the fact.

Jeevan, I can not stop laughing. 'Demolish the Morning Mist immediately'. What a joke !! I never know there are such nice jokers in Mangalore. You all know only to demolish but never know to build anything.

Jaggu, advise your heros to protest against movies with semi naked dance instead of enjoying it secretly. Advise them to help the needy and helpless. They do not have to be 'Gurkaar of society'. Advise them to earn and feed their family instead of being jealous of decent families who enjoy their life with hard earned money. Teach them it is a sin to steal others belonging simply because they can not afford it. Jaggu , Indian culture is to live and let live others. If they want to live like animals, book a train ticke for them to Bihar.

Because these guys are supporters of HJV and Sangparivar, these parties should support these families financially untill these goonds' come out of prison

Extremism is a cancer to the society. Please watch Babu Bajarangi confession in U-tube. He is more dangerous than Taliban.
We do not want another Babu Bajarangi from Mangalore.Police should brake their bones before releasing them.

Sujith Polali has rightly said. Todays world targets innocent people like weaker minority section, nuns, old men, young girls, falsely accusing on cattle transportation etc. etc. The culprits should be kept in the cage to protect innocent from these animals.

1 month Back: "Aakodchi Anna, Birthday Enna"
Now: "Enkeg yerela Ijji Anna, Akelen Jailid Budle Anna"......

Very Sad to see our sisters at Press Club. I am sure that innocent will be released soon. I remember Sarvanja's quote only for those guilties "Maadiddunno Maaraya" not for spectaros. Dear Siststers we pray for early release of your innocent loved ones. Allah Bless...Aameen.

STAN, DUBAI good to note you support & appreciating Nitesh & BJP Govenment rule in Bihar but if LAloo or Congress govt take charge they will remove this law like the same they BANNED POTA LAW.

The pan is hot now. The reality comes out and the home has no more support left then these stories are common. There are innocent Christians still in prison for nothing during the church attacks. Nuns and Christian youths were kept for no reason. Where they find justice?

POOR INNOCENT PEOPLE. THEY ALL SHOULD BE RELEASED IMMEDIATELY BY THE POLICE. THEY ARE THE ONLY BREAD EARNING MEMBERS OF THEIR FAMILY. THEY SHOULD BE RELEASED IMMEDIATELY WITHOUT ANY PUNISHMENT

Police also fix all innocents irrespective of religion. This is the trend going now a days in Mera Bharath (India). Hope all will understand.

Mr Jaggu,Before blowing the lamp you have to light the lamp and after lighting you have to blow it.

Where where you ladies till now if you really think your husband's and son was innocent? Which wife or mother will say their loved one's are at fault? I sympathize with you because of their fault you are suffering. LEt them be Govt guest for some time they will be careful next time.

Sandesh Kamath, Udupi first ask parents of whose children were molested and beaten up come forward and AIR SOME NEWS why they are hiding like their Childrens.

!!!!!PARENTS COME FORWARD!!!!!all need to see brave PARENTS.

ALL THE TERRORISTS WHEN THEY CAUGHT THERE ANSWER IS IAM A INNOCENT. THEY WILL NOT TELL THAT I AM A CRIMINAL.

Jaggu, First it was not VHP but HJV. Secondly these girls were assaulted, stripped, robbed and molested.
Please keep your silly Jack and Jill story for your uneducated society members………….

Another drama from so called protector of "Indian Culture". Shame on you.

If enough proof in Terror, thier family defending thier children they were innocent.

What is wrong families of four of the accused claimed that they were innocent!!!

Big blow to moral and culture policing. Vedike's took advantage to get popularity and respect from ruling party. Now poor family are suffering. Good learning curve to those would have taken law into hands getting high on agendas of mashrooming outfits, using jobless and youth.

Dear Ladies if your Husbands/sons innocent they would not appeared on crime spot and TV screens,their is no diffrence between terrorists and communal outfits both are not respecting human beings.

Nitesh Govenment rule must be brought in Karanataka. In Bihar If the officers are found corrupt their property will be ceased. If above found guilty they must punish the immediate family members also. becuase they are supporting criminals.

All the family member will say those people are innocent, terror suspects also said those comments.

SUJITH POLALI,Mangalore how hypocrite you are!!!

SUJITH POLALI,Mangalore how hypocrite you are!!!

Jaggu, Mangalore

Jaggu Dada, are you sitting in a remote village of Bihar and narratingl a film story released prior to our Independence in 1947 ??? Stop dreaming my dear... wakeup...

jaggu, mangalore

Really good comment from Jaggu and points are eye opener for all of us....

These women are claiming that their husbands are innocents. Shame on you, when the local court rejected the bail then these women come to press conference to claim that they are the innocents If they gets the bail then these women would not come for press conference to claim that they are the innocents. Where are they from one month and why they did not come for press conference at the beginning. Law will not spare them law should give strict punishment for these goons. Who are they to attack poor girl/boy students.

This press organised by HJV, these poor ladies dont understand cameras dont lie, live footage based on that they were arrested. Feel pity for the families, i am sure many have learnt lesson from this episode. I am sure these guys will think twice before their Boss orders such things again.

very sad to hear this,in todyas world innocent pepole are targeted then the real cluprit its our india law & oder system ,hope god will show his mercy upon this family ....

These are the parents/wife who spoil their children/husband by supporting them. They should accept the fact.

These are the poor families who suffering now.But those guys should realise the familiy responsibilities.Guilty should be punished at any cost.

First go and ask the forgiveness of those parents whose children were molested and beaten up by your brave heroes.

 I support VHP for the work dey have done.... but go against assaulting girls...because
1.Having part is not wrong instead being naked and having party is wrong.....its against indian culture.....
2.U know how we celebrate birthdays according to indian culture:
The b'day boys amma prepares sweets and gives it to her childs mouth and the child later distributes sweets to the guests and lights lamp...... the birthday boy then serves food for the guests enjoys it...
3.blowing of the lamp is not our culture... lighting the lamp is our culture.....
Im a youth of mangalore .....

People don.t have good awareness about crime and its punishments as they are educated.those who involved in the homestay attack case if informed prior to police department there was no chance of anyone's arrest,regretting is not beneficial now

At first they thought they can get bail-out and come out easly like last time Pub attack.
Now all ways are closed so they got an answer after one month that they are innoscent.
While giving pose to camera so daringly that time they didn't realise? now it is too late!!
Is anybody can beat black and blue anybody's children,daughters.

Sorry "this is our culture" this is the atmosphere wehre they born and brought-up.
Definatly they need some special ORIENTATION training. So that they will think hundred times before touching even their wife and sister!
" Good Luck" Jagarana Vedike.

Really shocking news. Govt should release the innocent guys and legal help should be rendered to the innocent youths without day. Demolish the Morning Mist immediatley....

Dont worry, there is vedeo proof.

Let the investigation disclose everyhting.
Better to not to comment on this.

Whatever it may be. The innocent must not be harmed or punished. People should not lose faith in the administration and in our justice system... Naxalism is one of the products of such injustice...My sympathies are with affected families. No innocent should be booked. Police should have enough evidence to book and arrest some one. Be them be muslims, christians or hindus, first and foremost they are human beings and lives in our society. They will have to face the society once they are released. If they are innocent as claimed by the members of family, the administration must release with immediately giving them a clean chit by calling a press meet.

Even Ajmal and Kasab speak the same language.....

Parents of Terrorists who are arrested in Bangalore also claim, their children are innocent. If innocent why it took so long for them to come in public

In my previous comments(on the day of these attacks) i had told that Taranath anna and Venu anna were very good guys.I still doubt that they were invloved in such acts.I hope what their family says is true,the police understands it and these 2 are released from police torture immidiately.

What they are saying amy be true. But Madams why so late in saying they r innocent? why cant the fact finding team , the videographer who shot the incident , the victims , these ladies n police agian look into the videos in a closed room and see what they are saying is true? why didnt Sharan Pumpwell help out earlier? where are the different vedike's which came out in full force why cant they help these ladies? what about the  deputy mayaor who took out a procession?

Sympathies to the families of four accused.Being said that it is too late to claim innocence of their loved one.The cases are in advanced stage and all branches of democracy taken this issue utmost serious.ON THE OTHER HAND,LAST WEEK THE TERROR ACCUSED FAMILIES ARE MADE VALIANT EFFORTS IN THE PRESS MEET THAT
THEIR SONS AND BROTHERS ARE INNOCENTS!!!!?BOTH CLAIMS SEEMS TO BE.........

AMMA, DONT WORRY THEY ARE NOW STATE GUESTS AND MAY BE GIVEN HONOUR OF BEING GUESTS OF THE NATION.
WHILE WE SYMPATHISE WITH WITH YOU THE LAW HAS TO TAKE ITS OWN COURSE...WHY THE OTHER ACCUSED ARE NOT GIVING EVIDENCE THAT YOUR MEN ARE INNOCENT ?
CONTACT THEM THEY ARE HELL FULL PEOPLE ,!

Very sad to hear,this is what happens with poor people,bcz of some one"s mistake poor father mother,wife,son full family standing on street...now who will come to release them?any group?any party? Mangalore youth must wk up!!!!!!
Dont work for any group or party,end of the day result will b same!!!!

All are liers,how can police catch them and put behind bars.if they are innocent,they are terrorist in our own neighourhood.Dont leave them to attack more females let them get good lesson by eating ragi muda,good photo daiji world